The City of Joondalup has agreed to scrap beach hire fees for VacSwim and school swimming lessons after a public dispute with the State Government. The city had been charging the Department of Education more than $20,000 a year since 2024 to run its swimming programs at Mullaloo and Sorrento beaches. But the council voted this week to formally exempt the department from the charges after a review of the city’s venue hire fees and charges policy. However, the exemption won’t take effect until January 1, 2028. The decision comes after the council voted 11-1 in September against an exemption, but then ordered a review of the charges. Cr Phillip Vinciullo described the charges as an anomaly and said the benefits of the swimming lessons warranted an exemption. He said having a positive relationship with the State Government should also be considered. “We will not always agree with our State Government partners, nor should we … but maintaining constructive relationships with key government partners while continuing to make independent decisions in the interests of our community is part of responsible local government,” Cr Vinciullo said. “This is not a blank cheque to the State. It is a narrow, clearly defined exemption for two established swimming and water safety programs.” Education Minister Sabine Winton previously slammed the city over the move and said the department had been forced to absorb the bill so families did not have to pay. She told the Northern Suburbs Weekly she was pleased the city had reconsidered its position. “I welcome the City of Joondalup’s decision to exempt the State Government from venue hire fees for VacSwim and in-term school swimming lessons at beaches,” Ms Winton said. “Our beaches should be free for everyone to use, including school children who are learning the vital swimming and water safety skills they need to enjoy them safely. “I am glad that the city has worked towards a sensible outcome that puts local children and families first.” Ms Winton said Joondalup was the only local government in the State seeking payment for swimming lessons at its beaches. Council members who backed scrapping the fee argued the beaches would cost the same to maintain with or without the lessons, charging for beach access was “almost un-Australian”, the programs taught life-saving skills, and the city should not risk a row with the State over about $20,000 while it is lobbying for millions in funding. Mayor Daniel Kingston also backed waiving the fees but said he did not accept many of the arguments in its favour. “I don’t accept a lot of the arguments that have been put forward. I think when they’re examined, I think they actually fall apart very, very quickly,” he said. “Do we really believe that a State Government with a $4.5 billion surplus can’t afford $20,000? “We’ve always charged the State, not families, and the State Government pays for this out of — as I’ve said many times — from mining royalties.” Mr Kingston said he believed the decision could set a precedent, with other organisations providing community services that were currently charged fees potentially seeking similar exemptions. “At the end of the day, I think if we do start this, the policy is going to come to an end, the way that it’s structured,” he said. “I can’t see how then we could tentatively say to these other clubs that we should hold the line on these sort of social value things.”
State Government in win after controversial fees at popular Perth beaches cause outrage
The move comes after a minister publicly criticised the city over the charges.



