ACT Chief Police Officer Scott Lee previously told annual reports hearings he was concerned that, because some evidence in the report was obtained through “compellable” means, it had implications for any possible criminal charges or prosecution.
ACTIC Commissioner Michael Adams wasn’t impressed with the stance.
“All this says is ‘I don’t want to do this, go to the DPP [Director of Public Prosecution]’,” he said.
“And I suspect the DPP will say ‘oh, I don’t want to do this, go to the Chief Police Officer’.”
As for the reasoning that compulsorily obtained material isn’t admissible for prosecution, Mr Adams said police had other tools that their disposal.
“Whether there is evidence that could be used for the purposes of charging is an entirely different question,” he said.
“And that would be answered by a careful reading of the report, because a great deal of the evidence I refer to … was not compulsorily obtained.
“Or, if it were compulsorily obtained, can be admitted because it could be obtained by other methods than those under the Integrity Commission Act.
“There is evidence that can’t be used, but whether there’s other evidence that can be used, whether, in the end, it amounts to enough, is another [matter].”
The Operation Kingfisher report outlined former Education Directorate head Katy Haire’s serious corrupt conduct could constitute offences under the ACT’s Criminal Code.
These included general dishonesty, conspiracy to defraud, knowingly giving false or misleading information, producing false or misleading documents and abuse of public office.
The Integrity Commission also determined former Education Minister chief of staff Joshua Cermadis could be open to charges relating to conspiracy to defraud and abuse of public office.
Mr Adams was asked whether he felt the police or DPP should be looking at pursuing criminal charges or prosecution.
“No-one’s sought my advice,” he said.
Mr Adams stated both agencies had their own protocols and discretion to follow.
The Integrity Commission Act 2018 means the Commissioner cannot recommend prosecution for potential criminal offences outlined in an investigation report.
The key word is “recommend”, as that suggests giving an opinion.
The DPP’s office has previously pointed to section 111 of the Act, which does allow for the formal referral of matters.
ACT DPP Victoria Engel SC said that was the only way her office could consider the report’s contents.
“I understand the Commissioner made it plain [in his hearing] that that referral has not been made,” she said.
Ms Engel took Mr Adams’ comments to mean he had chosen to make the report public rather than make a referral – which she said was consistent with her experience in other jurisdictions.
She added there was always a risk to potential prosecution if findings were made public (as they were in this case).
“We have communicated to [Mr Adams] that, given there’s no section 111 referral … we will liaise with police if they intend to pursue the matter,” Ms Engel said.
“I await a referral, if that is to come.”
Shadow Attorney General Chiaka Barry questioned if the functionality or effectiveness of the ACTIC was undermined if, when serious corrupt conduct findings were made, no prosecution was sought.
Ms Engel questioned that assertion.
“[The ACTIC has] different roles, including public awareness, public reporting and raising issues in a public domain,” she said.
“[No prosecution] is not uncommon – this goes to one of the other functions of the Integrity Commission of calling out this conduct, laying it bare for the community to see so it’s not repeated in the future.
“It doesn’t always result in prosecutor action.”
Ms Barry commented that usually, when it’s suspected a crime has occurred, an investigation and potential charges will follow.
“But in this case, where public officials should be held to a higher standard, it seems not to be common process for criminal charges to actually be considered,” she said.



