In October 2024, the NSW Director of Public Prosecutions’ (DPP) office disclosed a young Aboriginal person’s name to radio station 2GB in connection with a story about a District Court judge.
NSW DPP Sally Dowling later acknowledged her office made the disclosure and she was present at the meeting where it was discussed.
A NSW Legislative Council committee inquired into identity protections for children in criminal proceedings, and questioned Ms Dowling on 1 May 2026.
The Commonwealth DPP Raelene Sharp contacted her state and territory counterparts between 24 June and 2 July to discuss a letter of support for Ms Dowling. Various emails and text messages were exchanged, but Ms Engel did not respond to many as she was on leave in Singapore.
Ms Engel agreed to sign the draft on 2 July, and the letter was leaked to The Sydney Morning Herald days later.
The NSW inquiry report was highly critical of Ms Dowling’s conduct, finding she didn’t “cooperate sufficiently” with attempts to establish the facts, and that the “proactive pitching” of the story to 2GB “constituted a breach of the ODPP’s Prosecution Guidelines”.
A NSW Member of the Legislative Council is also looking to contact the Integrity Commission.
Dubbo Member of the Legislative Council Stephen Lawrence was involved with the NSW committee inquiry that questioned Ms Dowling, and referred the QLD DPP’s signing of the letter to that state’s ombudsman.
It has since been referred on to the Queensland Crime and Corruption Commission.
Mr Lawrence described the letter as a “concerted and organised operation to influence the NSW Attorney-General and influence public opinion” and stated it was intended as a “political intervention”.
“The question arises: how and why is it a proper use of her office to intervene in this way?” Mr Lawrence questioned.
“This, to me, seems to be an example of powerful people, members of a club, banding together to protect one of their own.
“This is an obvious attempt to comment on the evidence and influence the decision-maker.”
Mr Lawrence is currently examining ACT law to start a similar investigation into ACT DPP Victoria Engel.
Independent Kurrajong MLA Thomas Emerson is also considering a referral.
He argued the name of the “disempowered, young Aboriginal person” was used as a “political football”, and that Ms Engel should not have used her position to become involved in a NSW matter.
When questioned by Region , Mr Emerson said it would be a different matter if Ms Engel had supported Ms Dowling privately. Instead, she invoked her power as a public official by using her official letterhead.
“I’m not convinced that’s what we fund this position for,” he said.
“I think it’s appropriate for this to be considered as a potential misuse of public office … but no one connected to the matter seems to agree.”
Mr Emerson questioned Ms Engel about the issue during Thursday’s (19 November) annual reports hearings.
Ms Engel stated the letter was about showing support to a colleague, based on each person’s knowledge of Ms Dowling’s “character and integrity”.
“Our letter was limited to showing support for a colleague, understanding full well the type of role that she occupies and the pressure that comes with that work,” she said.
Ms Engel said the letter, “on my part”, was not intended as a comment on the evidence given to the NSW committee inquiry.
“I was only ever asked to co-sign a letter that was already drafted to the [NSW] Attorney General,” she said.
“I was aware of the evidence that had been given and my personal view of Ms Dowling remained unchanged.”
Mr Emerson asked whether Ms Engel felt signing the letter fell within her duties as ACT DPP, given she signed it in that capacity.
“It doesn’t fall within my functions of the Act, [that] is probably correct,” she said.
But she stood by the decision to sign the letter.
“It is, in my view, important to support and try to encourage people of integrity and courage to come into these roles,” Ms Engel said.
“Seeing what was playing out in NSW, I felt it was important for me – especially as one of the few female DPPs who inevitably do come under much more scrutiny than our male counterparts … to come out in support.
“I’m happy to talk about this [for the remainder of this hearing], but we have ever-increasing rates of family violence and sexual violence in the ACT; we have our first – in 10 years – overturning of a major decision in the High Court of the Court of Appeal … there are significant issues in the ACT criminal justice system that, respectfully, the community are far more interested in than they are about me signing a letter of support for an interstate DPP.”
Mr Emerson asked Attorney-General Tara Cheyne whether she felt signing the letter was an appropriate use of Ms Engel’s powers as a public official.
“I can’t see that this diverted from her usual responsibilities; indeed, she was on leave,” Ms Cheyne said.
“I can’t see that there’s any misuse of office on that basis.”
Ms Cheyne felt it was a “long bow to draw” that emails, text messages and a letter could amount to misconduct.
But she didn’t entirely rule out a potential referral.
“I will reserve my position, or any future position, once I have looked at the evidence overall,” Ms Cheyne said.
Region asked Mr Emerson why he hadn’t made the Integrity Commission referral himself.
He responded that he’d hoped someone within government or authority would make the decision.
But he’s now considering making a referral as well.



