Premium

RNZ financial crisis: How basic accounting failures helped create an $11.8m deficit

Business Investigations Reporter · NZ Herald ·

22 Nov, 2026 04:00 PM 7 mins to read

Matt Nippert is a Business Investigations Reporter for New Zealand's Herald, specialising in breaking stories about fraud and corruption.

Access to Herald Premium articles require a Premium subscription. Subscribe now to listen.

Already a subscriber?

Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech.

Reminder, this is a Premium article and requires a subscription to read.

Former RNZ chief financial officer Hilary Parker.

RNZ expected a $500,000 deficit and ended up $11.8 million in the red. As accountants monitor the fallout, a look back at its finances raises a bigger question: how long had the problems been building?

As far as set-ups for scandals go, it would be hard to imagine anything juicy resulting from a combination of stodgy accountants and public servants – but Radio New Zealand has managed to take these ingredients and cook up a true horror show.

A combination of flawed management accounting (including confusing operating and capital expenditure lines, and understating actual staffing costs) and institutional inertia in response to recent budget cuts resulted in auditors discovering in September – while preparing annual financial statements – that Radio New Zealand (RNZ) accounts to June 2026 were vastly worse than projected.

RNZ reported an $11.8 million deficit instead of a forecast $500,000. With cash shortfalls expected, a $5m credit line was established – illegally, as it turns out, given such borrowing should be authorised by the minister – and its overall credit card limit increased for the first time in a decade, more than doubling to $1m.

The buttoned-down reputation of RNZ has taken a serious hit, and its immediate future has been roiled by cascading job cuts – 58 will go from a current total of 347 – needed now to close what has been revealed to be a structural deficit.

Advertise with NZME.

In the past week, staff have been protesting about looming redundancies; the board has been scrambling to take stock and arrange an independent autopsy; chief executive Paul Thompson was shown the door months before his scheduled departure date; and chief financial officer Hilary Parker – who suddenly resigned days after auditors began asking questions – has not been heard from publicly since.

Immediately after Parker’s departure, and in the month since as the scale of problems and dramatic consequences have come to light, RNZ has reiterated these failings are not criminal and were not being referred to the Serious Fraud Office.

However, alternate wheels of professional justice may well be turning.

Chartered Accountants Australia New Zealand (CAANZ), the professional regulatory body for the tallying class, confirmed Parker was a member and said it was well aware of recent developments at RNZ.

“While we cannot comment on specific individuals or circumstances, we can confirm we are closely monitoring the matters being publicly reported regarding RNZ’s accounting and governance issues, as well as action being taken by other agencies, as part of assessing our own regulatory response,” a CAANZ spokesperson said.

The involvement of CAANZ, and its Professional Conduct Committee and associated Disciplinary Tribunals, is likely to formally wait until the outcome of RNZ’s independent investigation into the affair.

If and when it does step in, CAANZ is able to terminate or suspend members, and levy fines of up to $50,000 on individuals and $250,000 on organisations for breaches of professional or ethical standards.

Attempts to seek comment from Parker over the past few weeks about problems at RNZ and her potential professional peril have not yet yielded any response.

With an investigation soon to be launched, formal conclusions about the facts of what went on at RNZ are likely to only come in the new year.

“The independent review is expected to look at the causes of the financial result and examine why internal financial reporting did not accurately reflect RNZ’s position and the adequacy of financial controls, escalation, assurance and governance arrangements,” an RNZ spokesperson said this week.

“We are not commenting on matters that could pre-empt the independent review.”

This leaves the past as one of the few useful avenues to explore. An assessment of the past decade of RNZ accounts shows a relatively simple organisation: virtually all income comes from government, and the bulk of expenses is staff.

Adjusted for inflation, they show staff costs rose 38% over the period, with the largest increase occurring in 2024 when RNZ received a 30% bump to its budget as non-eventuated plans were drawn up to establish a television arm or wholly merge with TVNZ.

Tellingly, while RNZ funding started declining over the past two years as Government mandating across-the-board budget cuts rolled out, staffing costs continued to rise. RNZ staff spoken to by the Herald have talked of cost-cutting directives being responded to with ad hoc nipping-and-tucking, and a sense of institutional inertia.

In 2024 just over half of RNZ’s government-supplied budget went to staff. Just two years later it was 70%, an increase that was apparently only realised months after the financial year had finished.

The unexpected inaccuracies in RNZ’s management accounts, and the recording of a $2m land sale as income (when it should be booked as capital), are cardinal sins in the accounting profession and for good reason.

These rules underpin practically every organisation in New Zealand, from the largest listed company to even volunteer-run charities and sports clubs, to ensure bills can be paid on time and that operations are sustainable.

The distinction between operating and capital expenditure and income is as fundamental to accounting as the division of church and state is to politics. And while management accounts are rarely seen publicly, if they are inaccurate, it is akin to a business flying blind.

Sydney-based accountant Amir Ghandar, who also serves as CAANZ’s head of reporting and assurance, was unwilling to be drawn on what had happened at RNZ, given his organisation may well have a role to play in the near future. He was, however, happy to explain why these accounting rules are so important.

Using the example of an automobile, Ghandar says management accounts are equivalent to the instrumentation on the dashboard – providing real-time data on performance and problems – while audited financial statements are the warrant of fitness attesting to roadworthiness.

“With management accounting, you need to be getting a clear view of how much petrol you’ve got in the tank as you go through the year. It’s not going to help you if you wait until the annual inspection to work out if you’ve run out of petrol or your engine has overheated,” he says.

Keeping with the car analogy in describing the capital-operations split, Ghandar says the proceeds of selling a vehicle shouldn’t be treated as household income to be immediately spent.

“You still need transport,” he says.

“You can’t go ‘Look at the flush bank accounts, we’ve had a windfall and should get the expensive caviar’.”

Ghandar says these rules are fundamental: “It’s very basic financial governance. Without that view [from accurate management accounts] it’s very hard to see how a board or executive team can manage to operate.”

Veteran director Rob Campbell has spoken candidly about board-management tensions in the past, particularly how the former is often reliant on the latter, and has sympathy for current chairman Brent Impey and the situation he’s found himself in.

While not privy to any inside information from RNZ, Campbell said that in his time as chairman of Health New Zealand, staffing problems occurred when efforts were made to manage the nursing workforce where hiring targets were routinely over- or undershot: “There are definitely management capability issues in a lot of these state organisations.”

He stressed the issues he faced at Health NZ – “problems assembling the data” – were quite different from being provided with inaccurate data. The only first-hand experience he could recall grappling with that was similar was many decades ago during the establishment of State-Owned Enterprises in the mid-1980s as staunch public servants struggled to adapt to commercial models.

Campbell also raises the question of what else an independent investigator might find, given the slate of problems already disclosed at RNZ.

“There’s a saying that ‘There’s never just one cockroach’,” he says.

“You would expect to find examples of this earlier. These things don’t become dysfunctional or incompetent all of a sudden.”

Matt Nippert is an Auckland-based investigations reporter covering white-collar and transnational crimes and the intersection of politics and business. He has won more than a dozen awards for his journalism – including twice being named Reporter of the Year – and joined the Herald in 2014 after having spent the decade prior reporting for business newspapers and national magazines.

Latest from Business

'Sell it to another buyer': Lawyer says clauses can favour developers