Home / New Zealand / Crime
Ponsonby bar rape: Aucklanders Yousif Yousif, Sahil Ali jailed
Senior Multimedia Journalist · NZ Herald ·
22 Nov, 2026 06:00 AM 10 mins to read
Access to Herald Premium articles require a Premium subscription. Subscribe now to listen.
Already a subscriber?
Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech.
Warning: This article references sexual assault and self-harm.
A teenager who was sexually abused by two strangers she met at a Ponsonby bar says her life as she knew it was destroyed that night. At one point she only wanted to live long enough to give evidence against the men and see them convicted.
“I live in constant fear and distress,” she explained. “I can’t remember what life was like without this.
“My ability to connect to others was completely taken away from me ... I had to grow up overnight.”
The woman’s scathing victim impact statement – targeting the men, but also the justice process and the media – was read aloud in her absence last week as Sahil Shaukat Ali, 21, and Yousif Hilal George Yousif, 26, appeared in Auckland District Court for sentencing.
Advertise with NZME.
They were found guilty by a jury in August of targeting the 19-year-old at the Ponsonby Rd pub Freeman & Grey in June last year.
In a letter to the court after the guilty verdicts, Ali suggested he didn’t fully understand the concept of consent – a statement the victim and the judge said they found to be concerning.
“On any assessment, your offending against her was life-changing,” Judge Stephen Bonnar told the defendants as they sat side-by-side in the courtroom dock. “... I hope, if you take anything away from today, that you reflect on what harm your offending has caused her.”
A promise of safety
The victim recalled to authorities having consumed three or four glasses of rosé at a birthday party on the afternoon before the offending, as well as vodka and lemonade and later a bottle of rosé she shared with her sister. She continued drinking at the bar, with the defendants buying her Red Bull and vodka cocktails.
“She described herself as blacking out in terms of her level of intoxication,” the judge noted. “She readily accepted that her recollections of the events of later that night were patchy.”
CCTV and phone data helped fill in some of the gaps.
After leaving the bar, the group stopped by a Karangahape Rd vape shop to pick up nitrous oxide canisters – a form of recreational drug use known as nangs.
“The victim spoke of her being presented with a balloon and being asked to inhale,” the judge recounted from the trial. “Also in one of the videos that I saw at trial, the victim could be heard asking about getting home and one of you ... said to her that you would ensure that she would be safe.”
But the men instead drove the woman to Rosebank around 2.30am and Ali, while driving, reached across and touched her inappropriately.
“The victim described phasing out at this time and not being able to properly process what was happening,” the judge said, noting that she remembered it starting but not when it ended.
For that section of the evening, jurors found both men guilty of sexual violation by unlawful sexual connection, punishable by up to 20 years’ imprisonment. Yousif was found guilty as a party because he was offering encouragement from the back seat of the vehicle with words to the effect of, “Do you like that?”
Ali then drove to a reserve in Onehunga, close to where Yousif lived. The victim’s next memory was of Yousif raping her in the back seat.
“She described trying to push you away and telling you to stop, but you did not. You continued,” the judge said. “She said she was upset and in pain.”
Yousif admitted the sexual contact, which was confirmed by DNA, but claimed it was consensual. Jurors disagreed.
At some time after the car left the reserve, the teen recalled the others in the vehicle mocking her distress and pain.
Ali then dropped off Yousif and drove the victim to a seafront area in Wattle Downs, arriving about 5.15am.
“The victim described being upset,” the judge said. “She described thinking that you, Mr Ali, was the nicer of the two of you. The two of you ended up in the back seat of the car. You began kissing the victim. She, frankly, accepted that she may have initially reciprocated the kiss but that she subsequently pulled away.”
The woman communicated that she did not want any sexual contact, but Ali forced her into a sexual position, the judge said. He then tried to rape her, unsuccessful only because of her resistance.
“You persisted for a period of time, however,” the judge said. “You questioned how it was that Mr Yousif got to have sex with her and you didn’t.”
The teen was dropped off at her home at 6.15am, where witnesses described her as being in a state of “extreme distress”. She had been extra vulnerable that morning, the judge said, due in part to her diminutive stature, her flat phone and not having her house keys.
‘Cannot trust anyone’
That morning not only shattered her innocence but permanently altered her sense of safety, she told the court in a lengthy and detailed victim impact statement.
“Now I know you cannot trust anyone in the world,” she explained, adding that she resents having to talk about her ongoing vulnerabilities to get justice. “I go through constant panic attacks, no matter what setting I’m in.”
There are frequent nightmares and sleepless nights, she said. She was unable to leave her house for weeks after the assaults and unable to go out at night for more than five months. She couldn’t return to her university studies for the rest of the year and to this day, avoids the area of Ponsonby where she met the defendants.
She said she can’t even shower normally anymore, resulting in flashbacks to the morning after, and it took more than a year to sip alcohol again.
The teen described losing her self-confidence and her dreams for the future, including becoming a mother or having a romantic relationship.
“I cannot imagine bringing someone into this world knowing that they could one day experience what I have,” she explained. “I cannot allow what happened to me to even be a possibility for someone I brought into this world.”
The victim described her two days in the witness box during the trial, during which her credibility was challenged, as one of the most excruciating experiences of her life.
“While I’m grateful to police, I think it’s important to point out how dehumanising this entire process can be,” she said, also criticising the media for a “sick and twisted” account of the rape allegations shortly after the men’s arrests that she said was far too detailed.
The victim had initially planned to attend the sentencing remotely but changed her mind, Crown prosecutor Elena Mok told the judge. She requested that the entire statement be read aloud anyway.
Defence lawyer Oliver Salt, representing Yousif, urged the judge to “exercise some caution” when considering the degree of violation, the fact of multiple offenders and the scale of the offending.
“The rape itself, while Mr Ali and Mr Yousif were there, doesn’t have the elements of a gang rape,” he contended, arguing that his client’s offending was “more opportunistic” than premeditated.
It was noted that Yousif moved to New Zealand in 2015 after growing up with religious persecution in Iraq and in a war zone in Syria.
The judge allowed a 5% sentence reduction for his background but said there appeared to be no significant causative link between the offending and his childhood.
“The norms of New Zealand society and expectations, I am confident you are aware of them,” he said, noting that the defendant has been in a relationship for six years.
It was concerning, the judge said, that Yousif told a probation officer that he had no drinking problems or mental health issues, then asked if it would help him at sentencing if he said he did. There appeared to be a lack of remorse or insight, Judge Bonnar said.
He ordered a starting point of eight years for the rape, then uplifted the sentence by one year for encouraging Ali during the first violation. The nominal reduction for his background resulted in an end sentence of eight years and six months’ imprisonment.
Meanwhile, Ali’s lawyer, Richard Keam, sought 55% in sentence reductions for his younger age, his difficult childhood in Fiji, the impact prison would have on his family and for the difficulty of serving a prison sentence as a foreign national. The judge allowed 25%, resulting in an end sentence of five years and eight months.
He described the younger defendant as having minimised his crimes.
“You accepted that the victim told you at the beach that she had not wanted the sex that had occurred with Mr Yusif,” Judge Bonnar noted. “And you said that you had not realised that until that point. You said that the victim was happy until your friends got back into the car.”
He noted that during a pre-sentencing interview with a probation officer, Ali only mentioned remorse after a discussion about potential sentencing discounts.
It was suggested by the defence that the harm caused by Ali was minimal compared to the rape committed by his co-defendant.
“I soundly reject that,” the judge said.
‘Life sentence of trauma’
The victim described the men’s lack of apology and refusal “to acknowledge their appalling actions” during her “year of torment” as another example of their cowardly behaviour.
“Not once was my voice heard that night,” she said. “Never once did they consider me a person or an equal by any means. They saw me as an object to do whatever they wanted ...
“It’s unacceptable to be in 2026 and not understand the concept of consent, or not care if it’s given or not.”
In her victim impact statement, written before the sentencing, the woman said it’s doubtful any sentence they received would compensate for what they did to her.
“You’ve given me a life sentence of trauma, and for that I’ll never forgive you,” she said. “You had to take away my power just to feel as if you had any of your own.”
She now bears the scars of self-harm, which she said was, for a time, the only way she knew to cope with the trauma.
“The only way I could get through the first half-year was with the intent to end my life after court,” she revealed. “I planned to stick it out until trial purely so that I could hold these men accountable for what they’ve done to me. Then I would let myself be free.”
Society seems to undermine how difficult it is to live with sexual assault, she said, describing an “incredibly isolating experience” of struggling alone with the silent symptoms of PTSD for much of the past year.
“My ability to keep living and to move forward speaks to the person I am,” she said. “[It] does not lessen the seriousness of what you did or the impact it has had on my life.”
Craig Kapitan is an Auckland-based journalist covering courts and justice. He joined the Herald in 2021 and has reported on courts since 2002 in three newsrooms in the US and New Zealand.
Gang member dealt drugs from rehab centre while on bail for similar offence



