William Pike will miss a Group 1 ride in next weekend’s Winterbottom Stakes after his appeal against a nine-day suspension was dismissed. Appearing at the State Administrative Tribunal on Friday morning, Pike, represented by Victorian lawyer Matt Stirling, fought the charge sustained for causing interference to Jason Li’s mount Palacio when winning aboard Beyond A Doubt in a Bunbury maiden on November 12. But after the inquiry was adjourned to consider all evidence, a decision of dismissed was provided that afternoon. It means that despite being free to steer Cosmic Crusader in the Railway Stakes on Saturday, Pike must forfeit his ride on the fancied Rey Magnerio in the 1200m sprinting feature on November 28. Stirling argued hard for the stewards’ ruling to be reconsidered on Friday morning, saying the charge must be downgraded, especially when considering Pike’s very good record. “The level of interference could only be categorised as low range,” Stirling said. “He has a glittering reputation of safe riding and an excellent reputation under careless riding. “It was a low-level traffic offence and does not warrant suspension from a Group 1 race.” The stewards’ legal team said that the raceday officials were best placed to make the decision, and their judgment should be upheld. “It was in the mid range, and the severity appeal should be dismissed,” they said. “The stewards’ action is there was no room. The alternative is to be forced onto the rails. “There was a visible jolt as the apprentice Li steadies and clearly pulls on his reins. “Mr Pike acknowledged that Li had to steady and contended to stewards, ‘maybe, possibly, I could’ve given him another stride’ and ‘I really wish I’d waited that extra stride’. “The imposition of penalty is at the stewards’ discretion and there should be a strong favour in correctness of the original decision, unless clearly wrong. “The stewards are appointed for their knowledge and experience, particularly for riding tactics and need to protect horse and rider. “We put forth that the tribunal should not interfere with stewards’ submissions.” The stewards’ legal team also said the interference was certainly not low and suggested that among the four degrees of avoiding interference – easing, steadying, restraining and checking – it should have been classified as restraining and not steadying. “A steady is usually a suspension. It created an environment of danger and Pike’s action put the apprentice Li in peril,” the stewards’ team said. “Stewards took into account his good record. However, five days before (at Flemington), Pike was given a severe reprimand for careless riding.” Stewards also raised that Pike might only miss a meeting or two through the nine-day suspension given that Albany and Geraldton meetings – where he would not usually ride – were scheduled. However, Stirling said that if Pike was to only ride on Wednesdays and Saturdays, the penalty would be distributed over the next five weeks and that is not how it ought to be treated. Stirling also argued that the case at Flemington should not hurt Pike’s 300-ride period without a blemish, putting it down simply to the nature of statistics. The stewards’ legal counsel said that Li, being from Hong Kong, did not speak English as his first language and that his evidence should not necessarily be taken to mean ‘I overreacted’. They also suggested that the stewards had considered that Pike would miss Pinnacles carnival rides by that the penalty should not be affected by the time of year. “Mr Pike very prominent, well-liked and WA’s leading jockey. We caution against reading into the apprentice Li saying, ‘I overreacted’,” the counsel said. “It was specifically discussed and stewards were aware of Mr Pike’s schedule, essentially allowing him to choose whether he rides in the Railway or Winterbottom. “The penalty can’t change because of the time of year or reputation of the rider.” Stirling said that Li’s evidence could not be misinterpreted and stewards could have acted too quickly when assessing Pike’s penalty. “We’re accepting of the difficulty of the stewards’ job, but they are under serious pressure to quickly dispatch business,” Stirling said. “The stewards asked the apprentice Li, ‘are you saying you’re being cautious?’ To which he responded, ‘yeah’. “He was essentially saying, ‘I probably didn’t have to steady my mount, and I was being careful to ensure he did get through’. “It’s a matter of serious mitigation for Mr Pike and the only way to read this evidence, and you could only see it as low-grade. “You could not get a suspension above six days.”
William Pike’s appeal against careless riding dismissed, leaving him on the sidelines for Group 1
William Pike will miss a Group 1 ride in next weekend’s Winterbottom Stakes after his appeal against a nine-day suspension was dismissed.



