Premium

Plimmerton Farm deal would not be permitted under current Active Investor Plus growth visa rules, officials say

Business Journalist · NZ Herald ·

19 Nov, 2026 04:00 PM 9 mins to read

Access to Herald Premium articles require a Premium subscription. Subscribe now to listen.

Already a subscriber?

Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech.

Reminder, this is a Premium article and requires a subscription to read.

A $135 million investment of growth visa-holder money into a residential real estate project breached the Active Investor Plus rules according to officials, but it appears the regulations weren’t clear enough to deliver any sanction.

The deal, made by fund manager Private Capital Group (PCG), to finance the 380ha Plimmerton Farm housing project outside Wellington, was likely the single largest investment of Active Investor Plus (AIP) growth visa funds made to date.

The transaction surprised and incensed many working in and around the investment sector.

At least two competitor funds, Peninsula Credit and Aotea Asset Management, said they considered and rejected participating in the financing, as they viewed the underlying transaction as property development and not allowed for growth visa funds.

Invest New Zealand’s advice was that the transaction would “most likely” be excluded for investment from the growth visa category, according to Peninsula’s managing director Andrew Pryde.

Advertise with NZME.

After PCG’s deal was announced, officials took several months to react with new guidance and stiffened wording as AIP-approved investors eyed the precedent, hoping to pour a wave of growth visa money into the property sector.

In the case of growth visas, investments are supposed to be made into higher-growth areas of the economy, which excludes pure real estate investments (excepting build-to-rent development starting next month).

Documents released to the Herald under the provisions of the Official Information Act show that the view of the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE), responsible for Active Investment Plus (AIP) policy, was that “the current wording of the instructions would not permit this type of investment [referring to PCG’s Plimmerton lending]”.

Parts of the release were heavily redacted.

Invest NZ had previously informally advised fund managers that this type of investment “would not be separable from the residential nature of the end development and therefore would not be allowed under Growth”, the documents show.

There are two kinds of AIP visas: balanced and growth.

The growth category carries lighter investment obligations than balanced: $5m invested over three years as opposed to $10m invested over five years. The quid pro quo is that growth visa holders’ money is supposed to be invested in riskier, higher-growth assets, though this has not always been the case .

The scheme effectively sells New Zealand residency for time-limited foreign investment – since it was revamped in April 2025 , $3 billion of investor capital has been committed, $2.25b of it for growth visas.

Labour’s immigration spokesman Phil Twyford said it is “worrying that so-called growth funds were invested in property against the advice of officials that it wasn’t consistent with the policy”.

He called on Immigration Minister Erica Stanford to provide assurance that the investment rules have been followed across the board, “given her claims of large amounts of money invested in high-growth high-productivity firms. Otherwise, there is a question mark over her claims and the integrity of the scheme”.

Frustration and uncertainty about the rules

The deal raised questions, both inside and outside Invest NZ. One fund, whose name was redacted, emailed Invest NZ to “seek clarity”: “we assessed this lending opportunity several months ago, but declined to proceed on the basis that property development financing is expressly not permitted under the AIP growth category”.

“We have been approached by another AIP credit fund who also declined to progress the transaction on this basis, and in fact sought, and received, feedback from AIP that this type of lending is prohibited.

“We share the view that the underlying transaction is indisputably property development. We are therefore struggling to understand whether there has been a rule change that we have missed, or whether application of the rules isn’t being applied consistently across all managed funds.”

A month after the Plimmerton deal was announced, Invest NZ had “five or six” funds waiting for a decision on whether similar investments would be acceptable, their released correspondence shows.

It appears the agency had limited scope for action at the time.

Immigration NZ, part of MBIE, sets the investment AIP criteria for the managed funds to follow, and Invest New Zealand’s role was limited to assessing funds, at the point of approval and reassessment, on whether they met the criteria.

PCG chief executive Paul Carman declined to comment on how officials viewed the Plimmerton deal and wouldn’t be drawn on whether it would be permissible now, since new guidelines have been published by Invest NZ and the rules for AIP-approved fund managers have been made toothier.

Carman insisted PCG is not lending on property development: “no we’re not, we’re lending money for someone to service a contract, that we can’t talk about and you know that, and that’s not for a property development, that’s for someone to extinguish their build requirements for things they cannot do that historically they would have done in house ... ”

Carman said the Plimmerton funding was ring-fenced for core civil engineering for the project, including for site clearing, earthworks, utility trenching and sewer reticulation, and a reservoir and wastewater pump station.

As the Herald previously reported , the deal gave PCG-linked entities first and second ranking mortgages secured against the Plimmerton property title; Carman said it was ordinary course for PCG to take any security it could on its lending.

Carman claimed the under-bidder on the loan was a group led by Bain Credit and that two of the entities lined up to provide the money were his competitors, AIP-approved managed funds Peninsula Credit and Aotea Asset Management.

This is strongly rebutted by both Aotea and Peninsula.

Aotea’s executive director Will Carnachan said the fund manager was approached by a third party on March 13 regarding participation in the financing for the Plimmerton development.

“We received preliminary information and, post initial review, declined to proceed on the basis the underlying transaction was property development. We communicated this to the third party by email on 17 March 2026,” Carnachan said.

Peninsula’s Pryde said his fund was approached by a broker to consider the Plimmerton transaction, received a view from Invest NZ that it would “most likely be considered a balanced category investment given it is a primarily residential and commercial property” and confirmed to Bain Capital that it was unable to participate.

Carman also asked that PCG be judged on the growth it is achieving. He said that in the last year, revenue for the businesses it’s invested in, across both its infrastructure and private credit funds, has grown 19%.

The rules for allowable growth visa investments, as they were set out in June, stated: “Where a managed fund’s investment mandate includes property assets, Invest NZ will need to be satisfied that the investee entities come with the above sectors, or another sector [this reference includes infrastructure] that will deliver economic and other positive impacts for New Zealand (excluding pure residential, commercial or industrial real estate).”

In September, the Government added new guidance, which reads, in part: “For the avoidance of doubt, Invest NZ will generally not regard infrastructure that is developed solely or primarily to enable a residential property development as a standalone infrastructure ... this includes, for example, roads, water, waste water, storm water, utility networks, earthworks and other enabling infrastructure that forms an integral part of a residential real estate subdivision or housing development.”

A stiffening of AIP rules at the end of September also sharpened and broadened Invest NZ’s ability to suspend AIP-approved managed funds and revoke acceptable-investment status.

This includes where investment no longer meets, or risks failing to meet, the criteria and also covers the likes of reputational risk to the programme.

Stacey O’Dowd, border and funding immigration policy manager at MBIE, said the rule changes resulted from the 12-month review of the AIP programme, which began in April.

Visa holders’ investments made before a fund’s revocation continue to be treated as acceptable investments.

Persuading the minister’s office

Immigration Minister Erica Stanford said she has addressed the problem: “I have always been clear that we were taking a very active approach to monitoring the Active Investment Plus visa and that guidance and immigration instructions would be changed as necessary. In this instance, I was advised by officials that they recommended that further clarification be made around infrastructure investments in the Growth category. Invest NZ issued revised guidance in September.”

However, initially, the Plimmerton deal appeared to pique little curiosity in the minister’s office.

A Herald OIA to Stanford shows PCG kept in close touch with the minister’s staff before and after announcing the deal.

Email exchanges between Stanford’s adviser Kara Isaac and PCG’s director of investor relations, Erin Grueber (previously a staffer at Invest NZ who worked on the AIP programme until August 2025), show PCG shared advance details of its deal press release and followed up about a related news story.

Grueber noted happily of a BusinessDesk story, “we were happy with the tone/balance in the way it was written – more of a focus on the infrastructure aspect than anything property-related”. She punctuated the note with a flexed arm emoji.

Both before and after the deal was announced, Grueber emailed both Isaac and Stanford’s press secretary Vikki Carter to emphasise that the Plimmerton loan was not a property deal.

After the deal was made public, Grueber wrote to the pair: “we realise now that we should have ‘played more offence’ on the PR side of this when the deal went public and shared more info about the big infra aspect of the deal from the outset – both in the press, and in direct comms with partners/stakeholders ... since sharing this extra info, feedback has been resoundingly positive – it’s a good reminder that the classic NZ tall poppy phenomenon is alive and well, but that people just really want to know what’s going on”.

Stay ahead with the latest market moves, corporate updates, and economic insights by subscribing to our Business newsletter – your essential weekly round-up of all the business news you need.

Latest from Business

'Pretty scary': Jobs axed at Sport Nation radio station as MediaWorks, Aussies move in