Premium

All Blacks defence: How opponents have opened the way to scoring more tries – Paul Lewis

Contributing Sports Writer · NZ Herald ·

20 Nov, 2026 01:01 AM 5 mins to read

Paul Lewis writes about rugby, cricket, league, football, yachting, golf, the Olympics and Commonwealth Games.

Access to Herald Premium articles require a Premium subscription. Subscribe now to listen.

Already a subscriber?

Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech.

Reminder, this is a Premium article and requires a subscription to read.

Advertise with NZME.

All Blacks v England – 3.10am, Sunday

After Wales ran in five tries against the All Blacks, a friend asked: “Do you think the All Blacks are easier to score against these days, or is it just that they are losing more matches than they used to?”

Other than a vague feeling both might be true, I had to admit I didn’t know – but a look at the record books paints an interesting picture and shows that Dave Rennie’s All Blacks will equal an unwanted record if they lose to England this weekend.

Over the past 30 years, the All Blacks have lost four or more tests in a season only five times. The record low point was the five lost consecutively in 1998 in a horror run (the 1949 All Blacks lost six tests, but that is discounted here as it involved two separate All Blacks teams on tour simultaneously in South Africa and Australia). Rennie’s team have now lost four this season (as also happened in 2009, 2022 and 2024). So three of the five worst season records in the last 30 years have come in the past four years.

None of this is intended to suggest Rennie is under threat. The man was parachuted in to take over from Scott Robertson and his first season included four tests against the double world champion Springboks , three of them in South Africa. Some leeway must be accorded there.

However, the plain fact is that, lose to England and with one test left in the calendar at the Nations Championship finals , they will equal that 1998 tally.

So, what about the feeling that teams are scoring more tries against the All Blacks these days? We looked at the All Blacks’ try-scoring, for and against, in four of the past five years – 2022, 2024, 2025 and so far in 2026. We excluded 2023 as it was a World Cup year and the All Blacks scored 240 points and 36 tries in tests against Uruguay, Namibia and Italy, skewing the maths significantly.

In 2022, they played 13 tests, had four losses, scored 55 tries to 31 against. The opposition scored 36% of total tries, averaging about 2.3 per test against the All Blacks.

In 2024, they played 14 tests, four losses, scored 53 tries to 28 against (including 17 in a combined 117 points put on Fiji and Japan). The opposition scored 34.5% of total tries, or exactly 2 per test.

In 2025, they played 13 tests, three losses, scored 52 tries with 34 scored against. The opposition scored 39.5% of total tries, or about 2.6 per test.

In 2026, so far they’ve played 11 tests (two to come), four losses, scored 60 tries with 36 against. The opposition have scored 37.5% of total tries, or 3.2 per test.

Based on stats alone, there are two main conclusions. First, Rennie’s All Blacks are scoring more tries than teams from previous years. They outdid the Springboks 17-13 in tries over four tests, so it wasn’t their creativity that cost them the series. Second, they are also letting more in than in recent years, with a slight but visible rise in the number of tries scored against the All Blacks over those four years, under three different coaches.

Disclaimer time, as with any collection of stats: it’s a small sample and, though we compared years with highly similar fixtures, there are always some differences. Benchmark teams like the Boks were played in all four years (10 tests in all – for three wins, seven losses). England have also been played over those years – for two wins, a draw and a loss (before this weekend’s clash).

It must also be said there have been law changes in recent times that might colour findings. It is now easier, for example, to score tries from rolling mauls . Though there seem to be more penalties awarded than at any time in the past, World Rugby stats suggest that penalty counts in tests have not dramatically increased.

Some will point to these statistics as proof the All Blacks have lost their “aura”; others that the rest of the world has caught up. Those inclined to panic and finger-point will have a crack at defence coach Tana Umaga, but there is probably no other facet of rugby so dependent on collective player decisions and judgment in the moment. “D”, as they call it, is a state of mind as much as technique and some glaring individual errors – like Leroy Carter’s in South Africa – occur under pressure. So would ditching Umaga and bringing in a new defence coach help? Highly doubtful.

The laws of the game, favouring defences, don’t help, especially with the All Blacks continuing to play their high-speed, high-risk attacking game , naturally raising the possibility of an error rate from which opposing teams can profit. Northern Hemisphere and Springbok sides have been adept at swarming the All Blacks defensively.

An attacking side is also more vulnerable to opposition that runs the ball back at them. The Boks, France, England, Ireland and now Wales have all demonstrated that in recent years.

The defeat to Wales in Cardiff was an error of complacency by coaches, selectors and players. It will likely not happen again. That said, Rennie’s All Blacks can clearly do with more work on stopping the opposition scoring quite as freely as they are.

Is Henry Nicholls the most underappreciated player in Black Caps history?