The decision in the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) may affect people who sold and bought property due to separation but had been granted a stamp duty concession only for the ACT Revenue Office to reverse its decisions years later.
It is the latest setback for the Territory’s tax collector, which has faced fierce criticism for the way it operates and deals with taxpayers.
Region reported in August that the ACT Revenue Office was facing a clutch of appeals against its retrospective stamp duty assessments, with many involving separated couples angry at how their eligibility for the Home Buyers Concession Scheme had been denied.
Appeals to ACAT flowed after a damning report from the ACT Auditor-General found the ACT Revenue Office failed to explain its complex eligibility requirements, relied on self-assessment and then pursued debtors without regard to their circumstances or financial situation.
It was revealed last year the ACT Revenue Office was chasing thousands of people who had inadvertently filled out their applications for stamp duty concessions incorrectly or were now deemed ineligible, sometimes years later.
The report echoed a Legislative Assembly committee inquiry that found the application process was unclear and the ACT Revenue Office was aggressive and inconsiderate in applying penalties and recovering debts.
Some also accused the Revenue Office of nitpicking and finding technicalities to frustrate the intent of the stamp duty exemption for separating couples forced to sell their shared property and purchase anew as singles.
A recent decision by Senior Member Jennifer Francis found for an applicant who had been retrospectively denied the concession and slugged with $33,845 in duty, including penalty tax ($8,461.25) and interest ($9,158.71).
The assessment came two years after the applicant bought a home in February 2022, 10 months after they sold a property jointly owned with their former partner.
The ACT Revenue Office argued there could not be any concession because the exchange of contracts for the sale of the first home (15 May 2021) and the realisation of the sale in June 2021 occurred before Family Court orders took effect in July 2021.
It said that having been sold before the court orders took effect, the home could not be characterised as an interest required to be relinquished by orders of the Family Court, despite there being an exemption or carve-out for such situations.
But Ms Francis did not agree. “The effect of the respondent’s argument is … to render the court orders nugatory,” she found.
She called the ACT Revenue Office’s position a distraction from the real questions at issue.
The interest in the first home was one that the Family Court orders required to be relinquished. “The fact that the applicant’s interest was sold prior to when the orders of the Family Court were made does not deny … the effect of those orders,” Ms Francis found.
Expert support to achieve your property goals Access to over 40+ lenders. Explore home loans
The ACT Revenue Office also argued the proceeds of the sale should be included in the applicant’s gross income, tipping them over the eligibility threshold.
But Ms Francis said the sale of the applicant’s interest in their first home was not a profit-making undertaking.
“The sale was precipitated by their personal circumstances, the separation from their ex-partner,” she said. “Receipt from the realisation of the sale of their interest in their first home is the realisation of a capital asset. It is not income according to ordinary concepts.”
The ACT Revenue Office decision that the applicant was not entitled to stamp duty concession and to impose penalty tax was reversed, and duty and penalty tax paid by the applicant remitted.



