Not a public servant. A consultant.
It didn’t matter that the industry kept bouncing back from scandals to extract millions from taxpayers while delivering very little in return.
They just looked so bloody cool.
They were fitter, smarter and dressed so much better than the rest of us.
It was the same story throughout my career with the APS and NSW Government.
Permanent employees were left to do the boring admin tasks, answer the phone and organise the footy tipping comps. But whenever anything requiring serious intellectual horsepower came along, the senior executive service would summon the Big Four.
I’d watch them drive into our offices in their BMWs, swan through reception in their Hugo Boss suits and dazzle executives with the sort of confidence reserved for people who have no idea what they’re talking about.
The women looked like Meghan Markle in Suits . The men looked like Patrick Bateman in American Psycho .
They had perfect hair, chiselled jaws, expensive watches and the uncanny ability to make ordinary observations sound like revolutionary insights.
While Markle and Bateman felt superior to their public service clients, they also shared an important trait with them: a disregard for the taxpayers’ money they were given permission to throw around.
The consultants would be given free rein to disappear into a conference room for a few weeks, emerge with a glossy report full of pie charts, Venn diagrams and phrases such as “stakeholder alignment”, then present their findings to a room full of executives.
The bill would be $200,000.
And what had we learned?
That Aboriginal Australians were disadvantaged compared with the rest of the population. That regional communities had poorer access to services. That rising property prices worsened housing affordability.
Groundbreaking stuff.
I always thought governments could put the money spent on these reports to better use by giving it directly to the people they were supposedly designed to help. But nobody wanted to listen to the opinions of non-executives who hadn’t arrived in a BMW.
And watching bureaucrats negotiate fees with consultants was like watching a 17-year-old P-plater approach a veteran car salesman to buy her first car.
“We could produce a base-level report for, say, $100,000. But if you’ve got $250,000, we could do some rigorous modelling,” Patrick Bateman would say.
SES would have no hesitation handing over other people’s money. Shame you can’t sell your old car to the APS. You’d be guaranteed a generous offer, and they’d probably pay extra for a glossy report explaining why.
The PwC scandal should have been the moment the relationship finally collapsed.
A firm entrusted with confidential government discussions about cracking down on multinational tax avoidance was secretly sharing that information with colleagues who used it to help sell tax advice to the very companies the government was trying to catch.
The Albanese government promised to rein in the industry and bring more work back in-house.
But the consultants quickly bounced back.
Research by the Centre for Public Integrity found the Commonwealth awarded about $742 million in high-value consultancy contracts in 2025-26. The figures cover contracts worth more than $2 million, so the true bill is much higher.
It seems governments can never quite beat the consultants.
But why on earth are senior executives so attracted to them in the first place?
Perhaps it’s not just the expensive suits and overuse of buzzwords. Consultants offer something else: a convenient way to outsource responsibility.
Commissioning a report is often easier than developing the expertise to solve a problem in-house. And nobody is likely to criticise an executive for hiring a prestigious consulting firm. But make the wrong decision yourself, and suddenly there’s a lot more explaining to do.
So we can keep complaining about their fees, question their motives and roll our eyes at their glossy reports. Yet whenever Patrick Bateman walks through the door, the same executives who lament the decline of public service expertise seem only too happy to hand him another bag of money.
Some bureaucrats even leave the APS to become consultants themselves, earning considerably more than they did in government.
And that’s the real problem. We don’t just have a consultant problem. We have a consultant envy problem.
They’re like the cool kids at school. Nobody quite understands their popularity, but everyone wants to sit at their table.
That’s why they keep winning. And that’s why, no matter how many times government declares war on the consultants, the consultants will probably be the ones writing the report on how to win it.



