‘Why no,’ I answered, rather surprised by his tone.

‘Well, it’s a fine book, and everybody ought to read it. The idea is if we don’t look out the white race will be – will be utterly submerged. It’s scientific stuff; it’s been proved.’

‘Tom’s getting very profound,’ said Daisy, with an expression of unthoughtful sadness. ‘He reads deep books with long words in them. What was that word we… ‘

‘Well, these books are all scientific,’ insisted Tom, glancing at her impatiently. ‘This fellow has worked out the whole thing. It’s up to us, who are the dominant race, to watch out or these other races will have control of things.’

‘We’ve got to beat them down,’ whispered Daisy, winking ferociously to the fervent sun.

‘You live in California…’ began Miss Baker, but Tom interrupted her by shifting heavily in his chair.

‘The idea is that we’re Nordics. I am, and you are, and you are, and…’ After an infinitesimal hesitation he included Daisy with a slight nod, and she winked at me again. ‘… and we’ve produced all things that go to make civilization… oh, science and art, and all that. Do you see?’

There was something pathetic in his concentration, as if his complacency, more acute than of old, was not enough to him any more. (‘Civilization’s going to pieces’; The Great Gatsby , F.Scott Fitzgerald, 1925).

Some books are tedious to read. The never ending flow of words, the long drawn out theorising on topics, the endless conjectures, but then suddenly something happens. The author draws the threads together and makes sense… or seems to… and drawing in of other thoughts lying dormant somewhere where our brains should be.

At times, the author challenges perceptions we hold, beliefs we hold dear, the sense of identity we have, whether individually or based on premises of what constitutes the cultural identities we hold, whether through elements of faith, religion or lack of religious belief, the lives we live in the western, ‘First World’ environment of relative ease. That all our essential needs and quite a few not so essential needs are easily satisfied.

Reading Jared Diamond’s ‘ Upheaval ’, published in 2019, especially in his last section, where he looks at his homeland, USA, after having studied six other developed countries and how they have dealt with changes and threats, then examining America’s and Americans dealing with changes and threats, both past and contemporary.

A penny or two dropped when the question of migration was addressed.

Nobody seems to be at all interested in why people should want to come to places like America, Europe, Britain, Australia. Donald Trump did allude to a possible reason, when he described some African countries as ‘shitholes’, as if that was reason enough to dismiss those countries as irrelevant, and the people from them as, not the words he used, but historically appropriate, ‘uncivilised barbarians’, not worthy of the aid being sent to alleviate the abject poverty experienced in these ‘Shithole’ countries. But please don’t look back in history to see that those ‘shithole’ countries were the source of so much wealth during the European colonial expansion.

It wasn’t so urgent a question few years back, during the dying days of the European empires. News travelled more slowly in those days, technology wasn’t bringing the images of the rich lives lived by ordinary Americans and Europeans. The focus in those poor countries was survival as colonial rule was replaced by indigenous despots who had learned the lessons of rape and pillage very well, but instead of the wealth going to colonial masters in Europe, it went to the establishment of self serving corrupt regimes such as of Idi Amin in Uganda, Robert Mugabe in Zimbabwe, Mobutu Sese Seko in the Democratic Republic of Congo, Omar al-Bashir in Sudan to name just a few.

Using a measure of energy used, consumed per person, Jared Diamond outlines the disparity and how technological change has driven the migratory push. Comparing the ‘First World’, the 1 billion or so people who live in North America, Europe, Japan and Australia, the per capita use of oil and oil products is about 32 times that of the billion or so people who live in Africa. That equates to producing about 32 times the carbon dioxide, the driver of global warming, about 32 time the amount of plastic waste than people in the poorer, third world countries produce. Western, or First World lifestyles are consumer driven. Lifestyles people in Third World countries cannot even dream of luxury housing, motor vehicles, clothing, food, leisure time.

‘Until recent times, the existence of all those poor people elsewhere didn’t constitute a threat to First World countries. “They” out there didn’t know much about our lifestyle, and if they did learn about it and got envious or angry, they couldn’t do much about it…

… The reasons why poor remote countries can now create problems for rich countries can be summed up by the word “globalisation”: the increased connections between all parts of the world. In particular, the increasing ease of communications and travel means that people in developing countries now know a lot about the big differences in consumption rates and living standards around the world, and that it’s now possible for many of them to travel to rich countries…

… Many people in poor countries get frustrated and angry when they become aware of the comfortable lifestyles available elsewhere in the world. Some become terrorists…

Religious Fundamentalism and individual psychopathology also play essential roles.’ (Upheaval. Pages 412-3).

Diamond does not reflect on the colonial past which has been a major factor in the west being wealthy at the expense of the Third World which was raped and pillaged of its resources to build the First World.

Jonathan Blitzer is not reluctant to draw that line. His book, Everyone Who is Gone is Here , (Penguin Press, 2024) explores the transformation of Central American states, El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras into plantation economies which drove the original inhabitants, farmers, small business people, families from their lands to feed the demands of American corporations, aided and abetted by successive American administrations.

Each of the last three American presidents dealt with a major humanitarian emergency at the border, and each time the American public experienced it as a separate incident. One came in 2014, the next in 2019, the third in 2012. The latest crisis was always the worst, until the next one. But these were all chapters of the same story, which went back to 1980. (Everyone Who is Gone is Here; Page 5.)

Suketu Mehta, This Land is Our Land: An Immigrant’s Manifesto , (2019) opens with:

One day in the 1980s, my maternal grandfather was sitting in a park in suburban London. An elderly British man came up to him and wagged a finger in his face. ‘Why are you here?’ The man demanded. ‘Why are you in my country?’

‘Because we are creditors,’ responded my grandfather, who was born in India, worked all his life in colonial Kenya, and was now retired in London. ‘You took our wealth, our diamonds. Now we have come to collect.’

We are here, my grandfather was saying, because you were there.’ (Page 3).

The resounding message is that the comfortable lives we live are paid for through the exploitation of other peoples and they would like their share of the benefits.

Colonialism has sort of ended. No longer are ‘new-found’ countries being settled and exploited, the indigenous peoples pushed aside in the quest for newly discovered resources. What we are seeing in its place is an increasing disparity between workers, ordinary people, and the billionaire class, the tech moguls and CEO’s of major corporations accumulating wealth at a staggering rate while wages are squeezed, cost of living increasing while corporate profits soar.

And the blame game is played to direct anger at ‘others’.

It’s a game that has been played before. Many times before, but recent history in the US and in Europe. Oh and yes, here in Australia too.

‘Civilised’ people exploiting the unworthy, uncivilised, the slavery economy of America’s south and the manifest destiny of what can only be considered ‘God’s Chosen’ eliminating the indigenous tribes of North America. Similarly in Australia where European settlers laid claim to lands which had been inhabited for thousands of generations, with the expectation that the Aboriginals were to die out anyway, or the rise of nationalism and superiority of the Aryan race to re-establish German pride after being made to pay reparations for the war that was lost, and the crushed economy, scape-coating of Jews, and other unworthy people , and the genocide that scape-coating allowed.

Today’s scapegoats are immigrants, Muslims, coloured people, and anyone else who stands in the way of ‘us’, who ever the more entitled ‘us’ may be. It may be in local politics as in Germany, the rise of the AfD, Trumpism in America, or One Nation in Australia (and the LNP trying out One Nation inits shift further to the right).

And it is coupled with the rise of religious nationalism, Zionism in Israel, Hindu Nationalism in India under Modi, Christian Nationalism in the USA, mirrored to some extent in Australia as a definition of Australian Culture, and with it the attempts to wind back the clock to the halcyon days of yore, like the 1950’s family values which saw women in more traditional roles, the stay at home housewife looking after the children, abortion illegal, homosexuality criminalised. And yes, Trump’s MAGA line is being used by One Nation candidates, encouraging us to Make Australia Great Again, whatever that means.

As with BREXIT ten years ago, as with American politics and now in Australia, the support from some of the wealthiest people is financing campaigns, essentially ‘buying’ politicians and political parties. The influence of right-wing think tanks, supported again by the wealthiest, by big business, lays the foundations for policies which are beneficial to those who already have the most. Using consultancies to write tax laws, the same consultancies which advise the largest corporations on business modelling, ensuring the wealth generated stays where it belongs, with those who already have the most.

The accumulation of wealth to the already wealthy, increasing the disparity, is the problem no one wants to talk about. Where a CEO is paid almost 100 times the amount a person at the front line of their business is paid, but that person cannot afford rent or other basic necessities, while the billionaires earn more money with each breath they take than some will see in a year is an obscenity.

But the new ‘scapegoats’ are those employees. Bunnings are restructuring their business using AI, and shedding hundreds of jobs. The group Managing Director is paid around $5.5 million per year, made up in part with incentives based on cost reductions and profitability.

In the last month, Australian banks have announced redundancy plans which affect several thousand employees. The CEO’s being paid incentives to increase profits, shedding workers saves a lot of money.

I guess where this is going is to point out that if a fairer distribution of economic gains were made, to a large extent the problems, the REAL problems we face could be addressed. But it is not in the interests of those in power to do that. The back-lash politically is enormous. (Trump calls that the ‘radical left’, Hitler called that communism.)

But that is not possible when those in power are controlled by the real power-brokers, the billionaires, the tech moguls, the drivers of the AI revolution, business leaders.

The ‘Chosen Ones’ are no longer the white European Christians who colonised the new world, who capitalised the innovations of the Industrial Revolution and have ruled the world for the past five centuries. The new ‘Chosen Ones’ have their own agenda, as Naomi Klein described in The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism, ‘which explored the way states of shock and emergency – wars, terrorist attacks, coups d’etat, natural disasters – had been exploited by right-wing governments for half a century to push through wish lists of pro-corporate policies in the aftermath (from privatisation of land and state assets to massive tax breaks for the rich). ( End Times Fascism , Naomi Klein, 2026. Page 7)

In much the same way, LNP governments have rewritten the rules where government control over social legislation, such as the NDIS scheme has been privatised allowing rorting and price gouging. Or the removal of the so-called ‘Carbon Tax’ of the Gillard government, leaving the cost of repairing the damage of Global Warming to the tax payers while the resource giants avoid the while raking in the profits.

The rise and rise of the right, which is a newly dressed up version of Fascism uses the same play book as the Fascists of by-gone times.

The sense of entitlement, whether it be through racial superiority, which drove colonialism in the last five centuries, exceptionalism as God’s Chosen, also part of that colonialism, but with the sinister combination of evangelical zeal, bringing the gospel of salvation while holding the weapons of genocide should there be resistance to the rapacious greed of the colonisers.

But this time around, it will not be the cultural superiority of the educated west, it will not benefit nations. The beneficiaries will be those super entitled billionaires who control business and governments, who are locking themselves behind the barricades of gated communities and have a means to escape the ferocity of the forth coming apocalypse, the revelation of the end of time, the Armageddon, the final battle, heralding the coming of, either first or second, depending which iteration of God is worshipped, of the promised saviour.

The difficult, unanswered question has to do with fairness and equity. And they are difficult questions because it means needing to justify how one person can earn millions of dollars in a year, while other person who works every day to produce the profits of the organisation earns so little they need a second or third job just to survive. There are only 168 hours in a week, and some of them are for rest and recreation.

Linked to that question is the problem that we are a wealthy nation, we live in one of the best countries in the world, we have the space and the opportunity to address the poverty some people live in, but somehow that is a bridge too far.

It is easier to point the finger at those lining up to join us, to become Australian, but cannot grant them access. We point the finger at people who look different, worship differently, whinge and complain about the cost of living crisis and the fear of having Sharia law imposed on us, yet we will listen to politicians who point to, or sometimes create, our grievances, but offer no solution because that would go against their wealthy donors, potential controllers should they achieve power.

(If Pauline Hanson or Barnaby Joyce became head of government, who would be the power behind that throne? In essence, the same question posed by the ’36 Faceless Men’ campaign conducted by Menzies in 1963, pointing to 36 union leaders who were described as the real leaders of the Labor Party.)

Keep Independent Journalism Alive – Support The AIMN

Since 2013, The Australian Independent Media Network has been a fearless independent voice – holding power to account and delivering journalism that matters.

Running this site isn’t cheap. Rising costs mean we need your support now more than ever. Every donation, big or small, keeps our servers running, our writers working, and our stories free for everyone.

PayPal or credit card – just click on the Donate button below

Direct bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969

We’ve also set up a GoFundMe as a dedicated reserve fund for hosting and future improvements.

Thank you for standing with us. We couldn’t do this without you.