In investment circles, they say you should never catch a falling knife. It means that you should not buy an asset when its price is falling sharply but instead wait until it hits the floor. While this makes perfect sense, there is a contradictory message doing the rounds right now too, with plenty of property spruikers telling us the buying conditions are great. Come, they say, there are no queues, they say, you now have cheaper prices, more choice and stronger negotiating power. Who are we to believe? Confusingly, all of the above is true. The hardest hit segment of the market right now are the first home buyers, who are likely see a drop in the value of any property they purchase in the months ahead. This entry-level market really has been dealt a dud hand by Federal Government policies and interest rates rises. But it is not all bad news, with the upgrader market in a relatively good position in this market. To understand why this is so, we need to acknowledge that different segments of the market do not move in uniform. Perth’s post-COVID property boom was a bottom-up boom, where the biggest price gains have been at the bottom end of the market. (The east coast’s post-COVID boom was a top-down one, where the bigger gains were in the more expensive markets.) Data from Cotality shows that in WA, the cheapest quartile of homes have risen in value the most over the last 12 months (by 7.5 per cent) followed by mid-tier homes (4.5 per cent) and then the top 25 per cent of dwellings, by only 2 per cent. The trend is even more pronounced over the past five years, with cheapest 25 per cent of dwellings doubling in value over five years. Mid-range homes jumped 74.1 per cent, and the top-tier homes increased by 52 per cent. As property valuer Gavin Hegney says, as a general strategy, if you can trade from a market which is just gone up 100 per cent into a market it’s only gone up by 50 or 70 per cent, the chances are you get the best of the past growth and the future growth. But these price relativities will not be around forever. There is a statistical concept called regression to the mean that indicates that when something is unusually high or unusually low for a period of time, it will inevitably move back to its long-term average over time. This means the outperforming cheaper end of the market will slow down, while the underperforming top end will ramp up. Under this concept, it is expected that everything will eventually revert to where it should be on the ladder of price relativities. We have previously seen this happen in the property market, including the price relativities between different capital cities. This all means that the relative advantages of trading up will not always be there. Of course, trading up is not without its own costs, which include real estate fees, stamp duty, selling expenses and larger mortgage repayments. But if an upgrade is something that you plan on doing in the near future, doing while the price relativities are in your favour will soften the blow of these costs. And what about first home buyers who do not have the benefit of trading their capital gains? As the knife analogy explains, prices are widely expected to drop further, with multiple forecasters and economists expecting prices will keep falling until the middle of next year. If they are right — and this is by no means assured — entry-level buyers will likely see their value of their property drop over the next few months. But timing a purchase for the exact bottom of the market is incredibly difficult. And there is a risk in waiting too long, because at some point a lot of pent-up demand will be unleashed at the same time, and all that demand will boost prices Of course, many buyers will have no choice but to wait for interest rates to drop before they even attempt to buy anything. The reason for this is because of the paltry amount they can borrow under the high-rates regime, and the price of houses these days. The five interest rate hikes this year have this year erased the borrowing capacity of a median-income Australian household by about $88,000, or 12 per cent. That move has wiped out the $73,500 price drop on the cheapest quartile of WA homes this year, which now cost $792,500, and the almost wiped the $95,500 reduction in the mid-range market, to hit a median $942,000. While none of this is intended as investment advice, I would caution about jumping in to the entry level market at the exact same time as everyone else. Other matters to consider is the range of listings on offer, and whether sellers will accommodate your terms or conditions. Either way, renters will next year come under pressure to buy their own property, amid expectations rents will grow $64 a week, to hit $863 by the end of next year. At that point the entry-level market may start looking like the better option.
Kim Macdonald opinion: Knives are falling across the property market, but those trading up to a more expensive homes have got something in their favour.
Knives are falling cross property market, but upgraders have an advantage.


