A plan by the City of Joondalup to close more than a dozen playgrounds has been sent back to start from a “blank slate”. The city had planned to not replace play equipment when it reached the end of its useful life at 13 parks that it considered to overlap with facilities that were within 400m. The plan sparked outrage in the community, with several residents speaking against the proposal at this week’s council meeting. Several residents were particularly concerned about Leaside Park in Greenwood. “I have this sneaking suspicion that once you remove the swings, you then may go ahead and try to do something else with that land, and I’m not the only one that has that fear. Many people around the neighbourhood have exactly that fear,” one resident said. Concerns about Geddes Park in Duncraig were also raised. “When I was a young father, I had great fun playing in the park with my son. The park and the street then went through a period where we all became a bit old, but now the whole place has been regenerated,” another resident said. “There are new people there. A lot of houses have been sold and there are a lot of young kids under 10. “And at this very moment, when there’s a need for a park, the council has decided not to maintain it.” Acting director of customer and community services Nico Claassen said the plan was to add 45 play spaces. “This is not about reducing play spaces in the city,” he said. “It’s actually about maximising the distribution of those play spaces through the city.” He said the parks where play equipment was intended to be removed had not been decided yet. During debate, Cr Rohan O’Neill proposed scrapping the 400m catchment criteria. “While theoretical metrics like a 400m walkable catchment sound neat on paper, they fail to account for the real-world realities of our street layouts,” he said. “Features like cul-de-sacs, dead ends, indirect pedestrian paths mean that walking to an alternative park often takes longer and involves traversing barriers.” Cr Matthew Count then proposed to refer the matter back for reconsideration, which the council supported. “From what I’ve seen from the community, they’re more concerned about particular parks,” Cr Hutton said. “I think referring it back to the CEO to start from scratch is better than doing so with the stipulation we cannot visit this 400-metre allotment alone … a blank slate is better than excluding a particular aspect.” Mayor Daniel Kingston supported the amendment to scrap the 400m catchment criteria but disagreed with referring the matter back to the CEO. “Our community needs certainty about what is going to happen here,” he said. “Referring this item back continues anxiety within our community about whether we are using the methodology which has been presented in this report, or whether we feel that we need to then look at this more deeply. “If we just refer this back to the CEO, what we’re doing is we’re putting ourselves in a cycle where in a couple of months time, we will have the same concerns with a similar report. It’s important that we do deal with this conclusively.” Mr Kingston also raised concerns about the diagrams created to determine which playgrounds overlapped, saying they did not consider government playgrounds and the frequency playgrounds were used. Cr John Chester was also worried a substantial number of play spaces set to be rationalised were within the South-East ward and most proposed new play spaces were meant for the North ward. Kingsley and Greenwood Warwick Residents Association president Sonia Makoare agreed with these concerns. “These residents are living around these parks. They raise their kids on these playgrounds, and now raising grandkids and great grandkids on these playgrounds,” she said. “It’s like somebody has gone ‘Well, we’ve got all these parks that don’t have playgrounds. We can’t afford to do everything, so we’ll take some off those suburbs because they’re all old people, and we’ll put them in the new suburbs’.” Ms Makoare said she was very disappointed with council’s decision. “I think it’s disappointing that the councillors can’t make a decision on their own,” she said. “All it’s done is created a massive amount of angst amongst the residents when it could have been hit on the head last night and dealt with. “It’s just made more work for everybody. “They need to look at who actually lives around the parks, who’s using the playgrounds, and who’s going to be using the playgrounds into the future. “The life that we are looking at living in the future is one where no one has a backyard or a front yard for kids to play, so those play spaces need to be increased, not reduced.” She said residents felt the city had not carried out proper consultation. “If they had told us what was going on from the beginning, there might have been some older parks where the residents would have gone ‘Yep, no worries, we’ll sacrifice that because we love what you’ve done up the road’,” she said. Hillarys MLA Caitlin Collins weighed in on the issue through a Facebook posts in support of residents, and said she was disappointed with the city. “I understand that some playgrounds are rarely used, and where there is no community demand, it makes sense to use those funds towards playgrounds that families will enjoy,” she said. “At a time when we’re encouraging kids to get off their screens and outdoors, we should be protecting the spaces that make that possible.”
Hold put on council plan to close northern suburbs playgrounds
The City of Joondalup is reconsidering the potential removal of 13 playgrounds.




