A broken jaw drove Eliza McNamara to put this food into a blender. She'll never eat it again
She's no stranger to a traumatic injury, but Eliza McNamara's broken jaw presented a uniquely challenging situation
BLENDING chilli con carne into a “porridge-like consistency” nearly made Eliza McNamara throw up, but following a nasty jaw break, the Melbourne winger was getting desperately creative with her food choices.
Reduced to a liquid diet after a rough bump from Ella Heads left her with breaks on both sides of her jaw, McNamara suddenly had to navigate the “most challenging” rehab process she’d ever confronted.
No stranger to traumatic injuries, having broken her back in a gym accident in 2022 and subsequently needing to learn how to walk again, McNamara found the double jaw break uniquely difficult even as it afforded her more time to devote to her passion project centred around helping young female athletes.
Concern for McNamara after heavy clash with Heads
Eliza McNamara is slow to get back to her feet before heading to the bench following heavy contact from Ella Heads
"There were just so many mental hurdles to overcome. A liquid/soft diet for so long, getting no enjoyment from food, and eating is all you can normally do when you're in rehab. It was weird, and hard," McNamara told AFL.com.au ahead of the Demons' preliminary final against Carlton on Saturday.
"When I was allowed to eat, it hurt so much, so I had to slowly reintegrate harder food into my diet. Just having to factor in so many things like that, and the football side of things – your mind goes to funny places when you get big hits.
"It was a strict 'nothing over porridge consistency' for four weeks. After that, I had a really nice lunch booked with my partner's family, for literally the first day I was able to eat again. I just couldn't chew, it hurt so much to move the muscles in my jaw, and I'd lost all of my strength. That wasn't fun for another two weeks after, but it's slowly but surely getting there.
"I went creative with my food early, then it just totally deterred me. I was down at the beach with Mum and Dad, and I made a chili con carne, done all the rice, mince and veggies, and I blended it, and then nearly started vomiting eating it. The colour and consistency of it was filthy, and I don't think I can eat chili con carne again. So I completely steered away and stuck to soups, tuna, sweet potato, tiny bits of chicken, just shredded anything."
Adding insult to literal injury, Heads received a three-match suspension for the round five hit and was back playing before McNamara could even eat solid food.
"It was a double-break, left and right side of the jaw. They say a lot of jaw breaks – because of where the contact comes – it has to release somewhere else. That means the other side of your jaw as well," McNamara told AFL.com.au .
"It was an internal break on the left, which at the time, looked like I was missing a tooth because it had split enough that there was a big enough gap (on the x-ray), but post-surgery, it all came back together and my teeth were fine.
"Surgery went really well, he put in two plates on one side, and one plate on the other. It was the same confidence I had after my back – it is so structurally sound now, given the bone had healed enough by the time I returned to play, that it's going to be fine."
'Welcome back': McNamara's 'magic' goal fires up Demons
Eliza McNamara notches her side's first major shortly before half-time with an electric snap
The one positive from McNamara’s seven weeks on the sidelines was the extra time she had to work on her passion project.
Based on her own experiences as a young woman navigating body image, fertility and menstrual health while in an elite sport environment, McNamara created ‘For Active Bodies’ (FAB), a program designed to bridge the gap between sports science and young female athletes.
"It was a huge win. It was good timing in one sense, we'd planned to launch that week and had content to roll out, but I just couldn't get back in front of a camera with the state of my face," she said with a laugh.
Dogs chase Hawks defender, Dees lock in young gun, Roo re-signs
"So I had to put on the brakes on that side of things, but was able to dive into the logistics. It was great to have a distraction away from footy, and when you're passionate about something, it's so good, you get really engrossed.
"We've secured a few brands to work with, and from this month onwards, we'll roll out who the researchers are and start pushing for expressions of interest and start to get bums on seats [for a February summit]."
Juggling adequate fuelling for performance alongside body image was something McNamara – among many others – have battled during their time in elite sport.
Under-fuelling can also affect menstrual cycles, which can then have a knock-on effect on future fertility.
"I definitely struggled with it in my first few years, and really worked on it. Then I broke my back (in 2022), and it was this real pivotal moment where I could have gone back into those behaviours," McNamara said.
"But by then, I had my partner (Sam), and he's been great and the best support, as well as my family. To be honest, the first time I spoke about it with the team was earlier this year, and it was really hard, because I hadn't spoken openly about it at all.
Why watching on left star an 'anxious wreck' as Dees dare to dream again
"But it's so important, because there are younger people struggling with it, and if they can at least feel like they can connect with me, they won't feel as alone and less shame about it. And this is why we need this education.
"Social media presents one totally different view of female bodies and what's expected of us, and as an athlete, you often look totally different. Photos of you are posted constantly, so it's a weird grapple. Hopefully it shifts back to where it should be, where we're strong and functional, and 'look at what our bodies can do', rather than 'look at our bodies'.
"I was lucky that the club supported me really well and I had external support. But it's so hard – you might have problems down the track (i.e. bone stress injuries) because of what you've done to your body, you want to mitigate that at any stage you can."
‘No ceiling’: Why the Dees can win it all
Melbourne AFLW coach Tom Wilson joins Gemma Bastiani to reflect on his first year as head coach, as the Dees prepare for a preliminary final
The combination of societal, physical and mental pressures hit McNamara hard in the early stages of her career, but she now feels far more equipped to look after herself, her body and thought patterns.
"The over-exercising was almost a symptom of the mental side of things. I had no excuse to be in a bad mental state, but you're coming out of COVID (lockdowns in Melbourne) and are naturally anxious, and there's a want to control as well," she said.
"I really got into running during COVID, both to get out of the house and to cope with VCE. You lose the picture of what's a normal amount of running."
McNamara said she always wanted to work in the women's health space, but "didn't have the degrees to back it up", having completed a bachelor of exercise science.
"I paid for a month of LinkedIn Premium and reached out to everyone I could. Kate Mahony (ex-Sydney AFLW GM, now at Chelsea) was one of the initial mentors I used, and she was great in helping me formulate my idea," she said.
"Coming out of high school into the AFLW system, I felt really conflicted. How do I be an 18, 19-year-old girl like all my friends are, while still being a high-performing athlete? You're trying to uphold two completely different sides of femininity, honestly. You're grappling with eating, over-exercising, all these taboo things that are actually quite common.
"The longer I've been in the system, the more I've been able to mature and also get the support I need. But there's little foundational education around how to do everything right without putting all your eggs in the exercise basket.
"I've gotten funding for the pilot in February, and have already secured four great experts. The initial target is elite level athletes and AFLW players, but I want to use this pilot to prove that this is a valuable concept that all athletes can benefit from, and eventually introduce it as grassroots level, so we don't have one in two girls dropping out of sport by the time they're 15."
Don’t miss two of the biggest AFLW games of the year on Saturday when North Melbourne takes on Sydney and Melbourne hosts Carlton for a place in the 2026 NAB AFLW Grand Final! One $20 ticket gets you into both games at Ikon Park — or you can watch all the action on Seven, 7plus and Kayo Sports .


