Extending the life of coal-fired power stations could increase the risk of blackouts and price spikes as the facilities suffer breakdowns and require more maintenance. The ageing plants were falling short of their generation capacity by up to 30 per cent on average, while one unit missed the mark by more than 67 per cent in 2025. Consultancy firm Nexa Advisory released the findings on Monday in an analysis of coal-fired power stations along Australia's east coast, and called for firm national closure dates to prepare for replacement energy infrastructure. The study comes days after the Australian Energy Market Operator warned summer heatwaves could push electricity demand to record levels and risk shortages in Victoria and South Australia during January. Nexa Advisory's coal closure certainty report analysed electricity market data between 2022 and 2025 to assess the reliability of coal-fired power stations and their impact on wholesale prices. It found the power plants were often unable to operate at full capacity, falling short by an average of 23 to 30 per cent during the period and contributing to higher wholesale electricity prices. Some of the nation's largest coal-generating units performed worse, with one in Gladstone, Queensland, recording an unavailability rate of 67.5 per cent, and others in Eraring in NSW and Yallourn in Victoria unable to deliver almost half their potential generating capacity. The figures showed Australia needed to accelerate investment in renewable energy projects to maintain a reliable energy supply, Nexa Advisory chief executive Stephanie Bashir said. "(Coal-fired power stations) have kept our economy going, our homes and our livelihoods, but everything has an end of life and these generation assets are now reaching their end of life," she told AAP. "This is not an argument for closing coal before the system is ready - it's an argument for getting the system ready so we can keep the lights on and bills affordable." Repeated extensions for coal-fired power stations such as Eraring, the closure of which was pushed back from 2025 to 2027 and then 2029, robbed investors of confidence, Ms Bashir said. The report said governments should set firm, nationally co-ordinated closure dates, establish backup capacity and remove barriers to renewable energy projects. "When the goalposts keep moving, it's very difficult to keep planning in any scenario and in any industry," Ms Bashir said. "When we have firm closure dates, everyone can work towards them." Earlier research by Reliability Watch found 108 outages at coal-fired power stations between October 2025 and February 2026, including 90 unplanned breakdowns. Many of Australia's coal-fired power stations were more than 40 years old and needed replacing, Climate Council spokesman and former BP executive Greg Bourne said. "I spent much of my career in the energy industry and I know what happens when you push old machinery to its limits: it can be dangerous and risky," he said.
Keeping coal power stations running comes at high cost
Australia's ageing coal-fired power stations are raising the risk of blackouts and higher electricity prices and should be phased out.
