Premium
Deloitte Top 200: Celebrating great CFOs means supporting them, too
22 Nov, 2026 03:59 PM 4 mins to read
Access to Herald Premium articles require a Premium subscription. Subscribe now to listen.
Already a subscriber?
Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech.
Reminder, this is a Premium article and requires a subscription to read.
Tax Traders co-founder Nicola Taylor says it's easy to assume that high performers do not need as much support.
Some of New Zealand’s highest-performing finance leaders may also be among those most at risk of quietly walking away from their roles, according to Tax Traders co-founder Nicola Taylor.
Research on New Zealand finance leaders published this year found 63% of organisations with female chief financial officers achieved or exceeded their revenue targets, compared with 56% of organisations with male CFOs.
But despite those stronger commercial outcomes, female CFOs were less likely to feel supported by their boards and less likely to be satisfied in their roles.
The findings raise a difficult question for boards and chief executives, Taylor says: whether strong performance is sometimes being mistaken for evidence that a leader is well supported.
“What if your highest-performing leader was also the person most likely to quietly walk away?” she says.
Advertise with NZME.
“How do we know that we are providing our best finance leaders with what they need to keep doing their best work?”
Taylor is co-founder of Tax Traders and Taxi. Tax Traders sponsors the Deloitte Top 200 Awards’ CFO of the Year category. Finalists are Andrew Clark , of Port of Auckland; Andrew Murray of Fonterra; and Will Wright , of Fletcher Building.
She says finance leaders are integral to the success of individual businesses and the wider economy, making it important for boards, founders and chief executives to consider what they may be missing when dealing with their top performers.
“It’s easy to assume that our high performers do not need as much support,” Taylor says.
“It’s not uncommon to mistake performance for wellbeing and see great delivery as evidence that we are providing a supportive environment.”
In some cases, exceptional results might not reflect an especially supportive workplace. Instead, they could be evidence that a high-performing woman had become exceptionally good at succeeding while carrying a heavier load, she says.
That creates a risk for businesses working to strengthen their succession pipelines.
“We talk a lot about succession planning in finance teams, and we should. But if our highest-performing female finance leaders quietly decide the role is no longer worth the personal cost, we risk losing exactly the talent our organisations can least afford to lose.”
Taylor says she makes a point in her own businesses of checking in with “quiet high performers” as regularly as she does with other team members.
She asks them two questions: “Knowing what you know now, would you still apply for this job?” and “Are you still working in your strengths every day?”
“Sometimes the answer is uncomfortable, but it is always worth knowing,” she says.
Boards should develop a similar habit with their executive teams, particularly with people who consistently deliver strong results without drawing attention to the pressure they may be under.
Organisations have worked hard to increase female representation within finance teams and around executive tables, but Taylor says representation alone is not the finish line.
If talented female finance executives do not feel supported to remain in senior roles, some of that progress could be lost. Businesses would also risk losing experienced commercial leaders whose judgment they need.
“The lesson is that high performance and support do not always go together,” Taylor says.
“Sometimes we perform despite our environment and not because of it.”
She says recognising outstanding CFOs remains important, but a board’s responsibility does not end when an award is presented.
“If boards celebrate the commercial outcomes their female CFOs deliver without investing in the support needed to retain them, they risk losing some of their strongest commercial leaders and the competitive advantage they bring.”
The research was published in the Hunter Campbell Mood of the CFO Report 2026, produced in partnership with Tax Traders, Infometrics, Insights Exchange, ASB and Extraordinary.
The Deloitte Top 200 awards
The Deloitte Top 200 Awards were established in 1990 to recognise and applaud outstanding individual and management team performances among New Zealand’s largest companies and trading organisations.
All the Deloitte Top 200 winners will be revealed at a gala event on December 3. The event will be livestreamed on the NZ Herald website.
Last year’s CFO of the Year winner was David Muscat of a2 Milk.
2026 CFO of the Year finalists – Sponsored by Tax Traders
Andrew Clark, Port of Auckland
Stay ahead with the latest market moves, corporate updates, and economic insights by subscribing to our Business newsletter – your essential weekly round-up of all the business news you need.
Latest from Business
'Sell it to another buyer': Lawyer says clauses can favour developers

