Australia is unique among major economies in increasing its reliance on diesel imports this century, a new report has found – a dependence that costs many billions of dollars as geopolitical tensions rise, but that can be remedied by coordinated government action.

The “ Fuelling the Future ” Grattan Institute report by analysts Alison Reeve, Hamish McKenzie, Hayley Pring and Tony Wood finds Australia imports 97 per cent of its liquid fuel – a position that makes it enormously vulnerable to spikes in fossil fuel prices caused by distant events.

To this end, the report estimates that the US-Israel war on Iran, alone, has already cost Australians almost $18 billion and the federal government an extra $3 billion, while also worsening inflation.

“Australia has no strategy to reduce its reliance on imported fuels,” said Reeve, who is director of Grattan’s Energy and Climate Change program, and the report’s lead author.

“This dependence on imported fuel is no longer tenable – it keeps us tethered to increasingly chaotic global events we cannot control.”

The authors propose a so-called Grattan Fuel Plan, that would bring onshore at least half the fuel used by the biggest consuming sectors – road transport, mining, and aviation – by 2050.

Three key policies would underpin the plan, including setting and delivering on a target to have 650,000 electric trucks on Australian roads by mid-century that alone would cut diesel use by 5 billion litres annually.

To meet this goal would require the government to invest $1.1 billion in a national network of chargers and to dole out $2.4 billion in subsidies to help trucking firms to buy electric trucks.

A second policy pillar would particularly focus on the mining sector by capping annual diesel fuel tax credits at $35 million per corporate group. This measure would cut diesel use by 3.5 billion litres a year and slash government spending by $76 billion by 2050, Grattan estimates.

A third major component of the plan would be to set a mandatory target for clean jet fuel use, and require the largest government outlay – at $6 billion – to assist the construction of Australia’s first fleet of clean refineries. By 2050, airlines would be burning 9.8 billion litres of clean jet fuel yearly, rather than importing fossil alternatives.

The report lands as the Albanese government comes under pressure, largely from the media commentariat, to reduce spending in general but to target, in particular, decarbonisation programs incentivising electric vehicles and home batteries. Much larger schemes, such as the almost $11 billion a year diesel fuel credit, get far less heed.

The urgency of the liquid fuel transition is underscored by the complacency shown by mostly Coalition federal governments since 2000, with Labor in power about a third of that time.

During the 2000-2024 period, Australia has become the world’s biggest diesel importer, increasing our dependence on the fuel even as other similar nations have reduced their reliance on it, the Grattan report states.

The three main policy areas should be supplemented by others, the authors say, such as tightening the New Vehicles Emissions Standard “to achieve very high levels of sovereign fuel share for passenger vehicles.”

Similarly, EV subsidies should be recalibrated to target drivers least able to afford them.

Meanwhile, the government should extend financial support for Australia’s two remaining oil refineries for as long as they remain significant sources of fuel but reject pressure to pump public money into a third refinery.

Savings can also be secured over time by lowering mandatory requirements for fuel storage as reliance on imported fuels subsides, the report says.

The government’s present approach to fuel security is mostly focused on increasing the volume of liquid fuel stored onshore and underwriting ongoing shipments of fuel to Australia, the report notes.

“These measures help Australia ride out the next shock,” it says. “They do not address the fundamental driver of Australia’s fuel insecurity: the fact that Australia does not make its own fuel.”

In the past, making fuel has meant making fossil fuels, but technological change, especially the rise of electrification and development of clean biofuels, has given the nation more options.

“Today, a litre of petrol imported to fuel a car can be displaced by domestically generated electricity,” the report said. “Imported conventional jet fuel can be replaced by domestically produced clean jet fuel.”

With an appropriate policy mix, Australia could supply half of its own liquid fuels by mid-century, it said.

While the Grattan plan lifts some spending, the net benefit to the budget would be $55 billion by 2050, and it would also reduce fuel imports by 18 billion litres by that year.

Individuals would benefit, too, with a typical household spending $3,344 less on fuel by mid-century under the plan, and sharing in $3.6 billion in avoided fuel storage costs.

Should global oil prices spike in 2050 as much as have done during the Iran War, Australians would be $41 billion better off under the plan, the report says.

Australia’s efforts to cut greenhouse gas emissions, too, would be a side-beneficiary of this plan.

Emissions from fuel consumption, which have been on the rise since the Covid 19 pandemic, would drop by 58 per cent compared with remaining reliant on imported liquid fuels, the report says.

Overall, oil demand by 2050 would be cut by about about a third, compared with the base case of not acting.

Fuel use by cars – a sector which has seen EV sales soar this year, amid rising petrol and diesel prices – has already peaked, according to this analysis.

The trucking sector, however, has been slow to change, in part because of the absence of policy support.

“We forecast that under current policies, Australia will reach 17% sovereign fuel by 2040 and 33% by 2050,” the report says. “But this almost entirely comes from cars electrifying.”

“Without action, trucking, mining, and aviation will still be almost entirely reliant on imported fuels in 2050,” it said.

That’s why new policies, including the support for truck charging sites, will be key. Diesel use in the sector is about 8.2 billion litres a year, accounting for about a quarter of all diesel used in Australia.

“Almost all trucking is for road freight, the report says, noting trucks presently move 96% of the nation’s road freight. “Road freight has grown sixfold since the 1970s, and is forecast to grow by 77% again by 2050.”

Importantly, though, most truck trips in Australia cover relatively short distances.

“The average rigid truck covers about 81 km a day, and the average articulated truck about 300km,” it says. “Electric trucks on sale in Australia today can cover both distances on a single charge.”

“More than half of all truck kilometres driven are either within capital cities, or within 100 km of a regional base,” the report says. “These ranges can feasibly be electrified.

“About 30 battery-electric truck models are now on sale in Australia, from 4.5-tonne delivery trucks to heavy prime movers, with ranges between 200km and 300km.”

More EV options are becoming available for another sub-sector of the trucking industry, namely, the giant mining trucks that presently ship iron ore or other minerals in regions such as the Pilbara.

Fortescue boss Andrew Forrest has clashed repeatedly with his larger rivals, BHP and Rio Tinto, over their use of fuel tax credits to maintain the use of diesel. Mining firms should have caps placed on those rebates to prompt them to transition to electric alternative, he has argued, and the Grattan authors agree.

A $35 million tax credit gap per corporate group “would make electric haul trucks cheaper than diesel ones as soon as 2030, driving rapid electrification of mining,” the report says.

That move would cut 3.5 billion litres of annual diesel consumption by 2050, and deliver 50% sovereign fuel share to the mining sector, it says.

“And it would save the government money – about $3.2 billion a year, or $76 billion cumulatively by 2050.”

The mining sector, Fortescue aside, has largely argued that the diesel fuel rebate reflects that their trucks don’t use public roads and, hence, deserve to be granted the credits. (Miners make this case, as do many farmers, even though excise fuel tax itself goes into consolidated revenue and so is not directly tied to governments’ road spending.)

Interestingly, the Grattan report echoes a point made by analyst David Leitch in Renew Economy reports and podcasts for some time, that rising diesel use by mining is partly a reflection of the sector’s declining productivity as coal and other target minerals are becoming harder to mine.

“The diesel used to produce a tonne of coal has nearly doubled from 6 litres in 2007 to 11 litres in 2024,” the report says. “Coal miners are moving coal greater distances and replacing electric equipment with diesel.”

While government policy can support the switch to EVs large and small, “electricity can do a lot but it can’t do everything”, the Grattan authors say.

For other users, particularly aircraft, Australia is likely to need a sovereign supply of liquid fuels. (China has begun trialling 19-seat electric aircraft over short distances, but larger planes flying longer journeys will likely take some while yet to become competitive.)

Australia, though, is likely to require rising volumes of both clean jet fuel and renewable diesel, the report says, necessitating the development of local refineries if Australia’s import dependence is to be reduced.

“Our model suggests about 13 clean fuel refineries would be required to produce the 9.8 billion litres of clean jet fuel required to hit 50% sovereign fuel share in aviation,” it says.

“A fleet this size would require investments of about $102 billion over the next 20 years.”

While sizeable, that amount is less that the $6 billion-plus the government currently spends on “national culture and recreation”, such as the ABC, a year.

Still, “[b]uilding a domestic industry of this size, over this time, will require well-designed and comprehensive industry policy”, the report says.

Mandating that airlines use 50% clean jet fuel by 2050 from local refineries will be central to such a policy.

Governments should also provide capital grants to refinery projects where they demonstrate new production processes or feedstock uses that will be critical to unlocking scale, the analysts argue.

“An investment of about $6 billion should be sufficient to unlock the first wave of refineries before 2035.”

What the government should not do, however, is pour billions of dollars into local refining of fossil fuels.

The country has just two oil refineries left – Viva’s near Geelong in Victoria and Ampol’s in Lytton, Queensland – with both underwritten by the government.

That aid runs to 2030, and the government is considering extending a package centred on a $2 billion Fuel Security Services Payment (FSSP), alongside roughly $300 million for facility upgrades.

The two refineries produce about 12 billion litres of refined product per year, or about a fifth of the 60 billion litres consumed in Australia.

The issue, though, is that 86% of their output depends on imported crude oil, so it is not a sovereign source of fuel supply. “Of the refineries’ total output, about 2 billion litres is sovereign,” the report notes. “This meets about 3% of total fuel demand.”

The share of the crude being sourced locally is on the skids, as well. “Without new crude oil discoveries, the refineries will be almost entirely reliant on imported crude by 2035,” the Grattan report says.

“By the time Australia runs out of crude, electricity will produce triple the level of sovereign fuel that refineries produce today.”

Similarly, building a third, new refinery would not only be expensive, it would not improve sovereign fuel security without more local sources of crude oil. “Crude availability, not refining capacity, is the binding constraint on sovereign production of liquid fossil fuels,” the report says.

If some of the outlays for the Grattan plan seem large, the gains for the budget exceed the required spending.

The report, though, also notes governments in the future will need to navigate the economic shocks caused by climate change itself.

“Australia’s commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions are part of the global effort to minimise the adverse economic and social consequences of climate change,” it says.

And for perspective, if the government applied a “conservative cost estimate” by Treasury of $329 per tonne of carbon-dioxide emissions, the bill from offsetting 213 million tonnes of liquid fuel consumption in 2050 would amount to $70 billion – every year.

“Under The Grattan Fuel Plan, the same bill is $30 billion,” the report said. “The difference – $40 billion a year – is an additional saving for Australia.”

If you would like to join more than 29,000 others and get the latest clean energy news delivered straight to your inbox, for free, please click here to subscribe to our free daily newsletter .

If you wish to support independent media, and accurate information, please consider making a one off donation or becoming a regular supporter of Renew Economy. Please click here. Your support is invaluable.

Peter Hannam is a veteran journalist whose work spans almost four decades and includes stints outside Australia, including time in China, Japan, Singapore and Mongolia. He has lately reported extensively on energy, climate and environmental issues in Australia, and also worked for the federal Climate Change Authority as a special media advisor.

Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook

Share on X (Opens in new window) X

Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn

Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit

Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email

Print (Opens in new window) Print

Laws changed to allow coal mine extension blocked by High Court in state’s last act of parliament

Laws changed to allow massive coal mine extension – blocked by a High Court ruling on climate impacts – in the last bill to pass through parliament before state election.

Tethered to chaos: The crippling cost of Australia’s imported diesel dependence – and how to cut the cord

Australia has paid an extra $21 billion on imported fuel costs inflated by the Iran War. New report sets out how to build energy security while cutting costs and emissions.

Sycophantic AI models quickly abandon climate facts when faced with denier push-back, says report

Major new report finds AI is helping to drive climate mis- and disinformation, by pivoting at the first sign a user “mildly disagrees” to confirm some of the worst climate myths.

How the cost of concrete put batteries on stilts, and set blueprint for Quinbrook’s Supernode strategy

The Supernode battery and data centre north of Brisbane is nearing completion – and was first to use a novel BESS design now being rolled out all over the world.

Join our WhatsApp Channel

I allow to create an account

When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you’ll be logged-in to this account.

Please login or register to comment

Plan to build big battery in ex-premier’s home town will have to dodge abandoned gold mine shafts

Coal power offers “no chance to compete,” says Rio Tinto, as smelters go all-in on renewables

“Deniers and delayers:” Bowen marks 600,000 cheaper home batteries, but says balcony solar cannot be rushed

State adds $4,000 “discount” to energy upgrade scheme, targeting low-income households and renters

“Unbankable:” Fresh blow to Beetaloo as last of Big Four banks rules out finance for new gas pipelines

Energy Insiders Podcast: On the ground at COP31

IGCC’s Anna Hancock offers on-the-ground insight into what has – and hasn’t – been happening at COP31. Plus news of the week with David Leitch and Peter Hannam.

Energy Insiders Podcast

EVs are getting better – the real-world tests show it. Now we just need chargers to catch up

To me, EVs need to be able to do long journeys in roughly the same time as ICE cars. Evidence suggests they’re nearly there – given the right charging network.

It’s OK to mention “fossil fuels” at COP31 – then we can talk about replacing them

Politicians too easily push to be more “realistic” by using words like electrification as a camouflage for “fossil fuels.” This cannot be allowed at COP31.

Peter Newman and Ray Wills