Triple killer Sef Gonzales fails to overturn conviction as life sentence appeal proceeds

Naomi Toy NewsWire

21 November 2026, 3:59pm

Baby-faced triple murderer Sef Gonzales, who slaughtered his family in one of Australia’s most shocking crimes, has lost a desperate, last ditch effort to overturn his conviction.

But the 46-year-old will still get the chance to argue before NSW’s highest court that he does not deserve to die in jail.

Gonzales was a 20-year-old student when he strangled, stabbed and beat his younger sister Clodine, 18, to death at their Sydney home on July 10, 2001.

He then lay in wait for his parents Loiva and Teddy to return, stabbing them repeatedly in the killing spree.

In an attempt to make the murders look like a hate crime, he painted “F**K OFF ASIANS KKK” on the wall of their North Ryde home then later called emergency services claiming he’d discovered the bodies.

He was found guilty in 2004 and jailed for life with no chance of parole.

However the remorseless killer, who was thought to be motivated to kill so he could claim a $1.5 million inheritance, has continued to fight for his freedom launching several bids to appeal his conviction and sentence.

Last year, he succeeded in having his case referred back to the Court of Criminal Appeal (CCA) based on the claim that he had been sexually abused when he was 10 and suffered from PTSD, matters which he said were not known to the sentencing judge at the time.

He argued because the “whole case” had been sent to the CCA for an appeal on sentence, that meant the court should examine his conviction too.

But Justice Peter Hamill in the CCA on Wednesday ruled Gonzales’ contention could lead to “absurd” results and confirmed that the court would only hear an appeal on the severity of the sentence.

A date for that hearing has yet to be set.

In his decision, Justice Hamill noted that five different Judges have considered applications for an inquiry into his conviction or a referral of a conviction appeal to this Court.

“Each was urged to conclude that there is a doubt or question over the applicant’s guilt,” he said.

“All five Judges came to the same conclusion: that the application before them should be refused or dismissed.”

From the moment he was found sobbing in the gutter by police who arrived at the grisly crime scene, Gonzales has maintained his innocence.

He made a tearful television appeal asking for help to find the killer, offering up a $100,000 reward, and even sang at his family’s funeral.

Almost a year after the murder, Gonzales was arrested and was found guilty by a jury in 2004. In November 2007, he unsuccessfully appealed against his conviction.

Originally published as Triple killer Sef Gonzales fails to overturn conviction as life sentence appeal proceeds