Cam Bancroft believes his leading role in the South Africa 2018 sandpaper imbroglio cost him his Test career. Judging by the numbers, he has a strong case. Bancroft, who turned 34 on Thursday, has not worn the baggy green since he was dropped after the second Test in the 2019 Ashes series despite dominant Sheffield Shield peaks, albeit often followed by troughs. From 2022 to ’24, Bancroft racked up 1723 Shield runs at an average of 53.84, a scoring spree that featured seven centuries. On pure form, he was the standout contender to replace David Warner when he retired in early 2024. And what did the Australian selectors do? They promoted Steve Smith to the opener’s slot and swung Bancroft’s WA teammate Cameron Green into the middle order. It followed a return to form in 2020-21 on the back of a reconstructed technique that focused on an issue with his front pad, where he was regularly dismissed lbw or caught at leg slip. He burst back to form with five 50-plus scores in eight first-class matches at an average of 49.20, but received no phone call from then-Australian selection chair Trevor Hohns. For the remainder, it’s been largely about timing. In 2023-24 he scored 778 runs at 51.87 and scored three centuries, compared to NSW batsman Nathan McSweeney (762 at 40.11, three 100s). But Bancroft suffered a slump the following summer and McSweeney outscored him in Australia A auditions against India A. McSweeney went on to make his Test debut in November 2024 against India at Perth Stadium. NSW opener Sam Konstas made his debut in the Boxing Day Test that year off the back of a blistering run with the bat - he finished with 652 runs that summer at 40.75 - after McSweeney had been dropped mid-series after averaging 14.40 across three Tests. Tasmanian Jake Weatherald was preferred in late 2025 after producing 906 runs at 50.33 in 2024-25, while Bancroft was in a form slump (344 runs at 26.46). So far this summer, Bancroft has made 283 runs at 40.43, with an unbeaten 156 against South Australia at Adelaide Oval in late October that ended a first-class century drought that fell one day short of a calendar year. Konstas, meanwhile, has emerged as a leading contender to return to the top of the order with 426 at 85.20 and two tons. In his 4500-plus word tell-all published exclusively in The West Australian on Thursday, Bancroft felt by accepting his punishment for the 2018 scandal, he’d eventually be able to reclaim his spot at the top of the order. “I believed that, with time, my performances and conduct might earn me another opportunity to represent Australia,” he wrote. “There have been periods in Sheffield Shield cricket when I was out of touch and wasn’t at the top of the list for Test selection. “But there were other times I genuinely believed I had done enough to warrant selection. I had continued to train, compete, make runs and pursue the dream of wearing the baggy green again. Yet the opportunities I hoped for have not materialised in the way I expected. “Selection is complicated. There are cricketing reasons, competing players, different conditions and decisions that I have not been part of. “For many years I believed I would be selected because I trusted the selection process. “But I would be lying if I said I had never wondered whether the unresolved tension surrounded these events in South African had played a part. “Because in spite of having scored the most hundreds of any player in the competition in the last six years, including featuring in the top three run scorers for over half that period, I have never had a look-in.”
The case for Cam Bancroft: Why the Australian selectors should have picked him at the top of the order
Cam Bancroft believes his leading role in the South Africa 2018 sandpaper imbroglio cost him his Test career. Judging by the numbers, he mounts a compelling case.




