In his third statement in as many days since Cameron Bancroft came forward with his account of the sandpaper scandal in The West Australian on Wednesday, Pat Cummins’ manager Neil Maxwell took aim at “a hysteria unfounded in reality”. “When you go through it all calmly and in detail, Pat’s eight-year-long position and 68-minute Q&A stands up,” Maxwell said. So, The West Australian has compared the account Cummins gave at a press conference last Friday with Bancroft’s testimony — and they diverge in several crucial areas. ‘We all knew’ Cummins’ denials have been centred on the bowlers not having any awareness sandpaper was being used on the field in Cape Town. Bancroft later detailed specifics of the team’s plot to tamper with the ball, including his regular conversations with their bowlers. Cameron Bancroft “Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon (in 2021) released a joint statement denying that they knew sandpaper had been taken onto the field to alter the ball before the television footage appeared at Newlands. “Reading that statement was deeply painful. “I had memories of conversations on the field in Port Elizabeth and Newlands, feedback about the ball and shared celebrations that made the statement difficult for me to digest.” Pat Cummins “When he (Usman Khawaja) says we all knew, if by that, he means we knew sandpaper was going out on the field, he’s 100 per cent wrong. I’ve said that for the last eight years, I did not know that was happening. “I’m not sure if there was more than those three (Bancroft, David Warner and Steve Smith), but I did not know. “We’ve been very consistent from day one, that we didn’t know sandpaper was being taken out. None of that’s changed.” ‘Didn’t know it had been altered with sandpaper’ Bancroft said his new-found role as the team’s ball manager meant he needed to have regular discussions with the bowlers about the effectiveness of his work, which Cummins declared no knowledge of. Cameron Bancroft “I regularly spoke to the bowlers about how the ball was behaving. I had to. I recall conversations with all the fast bowlers Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh about whether it was reverse swinging enough. “The conversations about the effect the sandpaper was having on the ball were regular, very natural and organic on the field.” Pat Cummins “Even the umpires had a look — we didn’t know it had been altered with sandpaper”. ‘No master plan’ Bancroft’s account includes descriptions of team meetings where his work on the ball with sandpaper was spoken about, but Cummins denied there was ever a team-wide awareness ball tampering was taking place. Cameron Bancroft “On the morning of day three in Port Elizabeth, we gathered for our usual team chat before warm-up . . . I remember my ball-tampering with the sandpaper the evening before being discussed and my role being acknowledged in front of the group. “I received wraps and encouragement from members of the playing and coaching staff, especially (bowling coach) David Saker. “It reinforced the sense that what I was doing was being accepted as part of our collective effort. This event is crystal clear in my mind.” Pat Cummins “There was no master plan around using illegal methods … there’s no grand plan, there’s no team meeting, there’s no bowlers saying ‘this must happen’.” Umpires dropping the ball Bancroft and Cummins are also out of lockstep on whether the ball was tampered with after being dropped by the umpires ahead of the start of sessions, which was first revealed in Usman Khawaja’s autobiography. Cameron Bancroft “There was an understanding of when the ball could most easily be altered without attracting attention. This was an awareness we had as a team. “When we returned to the field after the break, the umpires would leave the ball on the outfield, a short distance away from the boundary line. “It was also what seemed to be the safest time to do it. Others in the group agreed and gave their opinions on this.” Pat Cummins “I genuinely don’t remember that being the case, so that was a revelation to me.” ‘No issue’ While Cummins — who was appointed the side’s captain in 2021 — says he has no personal issues with Bancroft and his role in the saga has not played a part in him not playing a Test since 2019, the West Australian says he often wonders whether that was the case. Cameron Bancroft “The final straw for me to write this account was Australian cricket captain Pat Cummins’ press conference. It made me feel angry, betrayed and alone. “My cricket career has been destroyed and I have never been able to play for my country since Justin Langer was coach in 2019.” Pat Cummins “I really like Cam. He’s my age group, I played underage cricket with Cam. “Of course, I’m not a selector, but from my point of view, absolutely no issue with Cam.”
How Cameron Bancroft and Pat Cummins’ accounts of sandpaper scandal diverge
We compare the account Pat Cummins gave at a press conference last Friday with Cameron Bancroft’s testimony — and they diverge in several crucial areas. See how their words contrast here!


