The last official day of COP was yanked out of its early torpor on Friday afternoon as a group of countries from both the Global North and the Global South threw down the gauntlet on the latest version of the cover text, calling it out for not naming the cause of the climate problem: fossil fuels.

Panama, France, Belgium, Finland, Sweden, Spain, Vanuatu, Cote d’Ivoire and Guatemala said they would not accept the text as it is, and insisted it must comply with six main demands.

These were laid out by Panama’s environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, who has turned into the star of COP31 due to his fiery speeches criticising the UN climate process. The group’s first ask is that science must be the foundation of decision-making and the second is for a clear transition away from fossil fuels.

“It is not acceptable to have a cover document that does not even mention fossil fuels, and we simply will not put up with it,” he said. “We need to tell the truth and to speak clearly.”

COP31 Bulletin Day 10: New draft keeps electrification goal but drops fossil fuel references

The group also called for high-emitting countries and those that produce or consume fossil fuels to stump up climate finance – something that will annoy China and Arab nations. They have resisted efforts by Europe and others to include them in the pool of donors that provide funding to help poorer countries tackle climate change.

“You pollute, you pay. It’s actually rather simple,” said Navarro. “If you are the biggest emitter of CO2, if you are the biggest producers or consumers of petroleum, then you must contribute to solve this problem.”

The other demands focused on clean electrification, boosting methane reductions and coordinating with other UN conventions that protect nature.

The statement was echoed by the Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS) which added its voice to those lamenting the lack of fossil fuel language in the cover text. It said this is imperative to emissions reductions, as the world is far behind on cutting greenhouse gases.

The group of island nations also insisted the COP “stringently” address the expected overshoot of the 1.5C temperature limit in the Paris Agreement, based on science provided by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and the delivery of its next set of reports in time for the global stocktake of climate progress in 2028.

They also called for stronger language on tripling adaptation finance, with a specific number attached to this, as well as starting the process toward achieving the goal. AOSIS wants the cover decision to reference the International Court of Justice advisory opinion on climate and human rights too, which was in the first draft but disappeared from the second.

“We cannot delude ourselves into thinking meaningful progress is being made if we agree to a weak final text,” the group said, adding that it would contribute constructively “to a final agreement that truly takes the world towards a fairer and safer future”.

Speaking to journalists separately on Friday afternoon, Australia’s climate minister and COP31 president of negotiations, Chris Bowen, said the key to transitioning away from fossil fuels is a transition to renewables, coupled with electrification.

“There is always a fossil fuel discussion at all the COPs I’ve been at,” he said. “This was and is a COP about whether we choose to deal with the [1.5C] overshoot or not, and whether we choose to electrify or not. The answer to those questions should be yes.”

He said the COP31 presidency was trying to steer countries toward consensus. “The work to continue to transition away from fossil fuels can and will continue. How that’s reflected we will continue to talk to parties about,” he added.

As COP31 weighs 35×35 pledge, IEA says Hormuz crisis driving electrification

It’s uncertain when the next iteration of the cover decision will be published but the COP dragged on past its scheduled 6pm end without one, meaning talks were set to spill into Saturday.

Besides the outcry over the cover decision, negotiations continue on a number of key unresolved issues including a climate finance work programme, the global goal on adaptation and a new just transition mechanism.

Some experts are concerned that governments may not be able to reach an agreement on some of these in Antalya, delaying them to future conferences. A ministerial roundtable was convened on Friday evening to try and bridge differences over the just transition mechanism. Many developed countries have pushed for it to be limited to a set of reports, dialogues and meetings while developing nations and civil society want an actual body to be established.

Brandon Wu of ActionAid USA, speaking on behalf of CAN, said developed countries have been hiding behind rhetoric around transitioning away from fossil fuels “to make themselves look like champions”.

“The deliverables from this COP were around just transition, finance and adaptation. On all of these things, the developed countries came with nothing,” he told reporters on Friday afternoon.

Some less contentious decisions that have already been agreed will be gavelled through on Friday night, but this will not be the final plenary. If all goes well, that will take place on Saturday.

African ministers cry betrayal, activists chant “shame”

In the meantime, Friday morning saw more reactions to Thursday’s draft cover text – with African ministers, global campaigners and a group of anti-fossil fuel nations holding press conferences.

African ministers from Ghana, Sierra Leone, Zambia and Senegal said COP31 has let down their people, especially when it comes to the lack of new climate finance and scant progress on key issues such as a just energy transition and green trade measures, which are needed to support economic development in their countries.

Activists came together under the Climate Action Network (CAN) umbrella to reject the cover text as it now stands. Speaking to the media, with a line of campaigners behind her holding up signs reading “Shame!”, Tasneem Essop, CAN’s director, said governments should do the same.

“We are calling on those governments – especially the Global South governments – to put pressure and try and fix things, clean up the mess,” she urged. “It’s of course not on their shoulders alone. We need developed countries to back down and stop blocking, so that we could still, in these last hours, try and save this COP 31.”

Mohamed Adow, founder and director at Power Shift Africa, slammed the Turkish COP president for saying on Thursday that delegates should leave Antalya declaring it “the best COP ever”.

“I can tell you this is the worst COP ever,” he said. “Overseeing a failing summit is bad enough. Trying to sell it as a success rubs salt into the wounds of the people who need it to deliver.”

Campaigners – who ended the press conference with chants of “shame!” – said developed countries in Antalya were backing off promises they have already made, especially on putting a number to a goal to triple adaptation finance and setting up a just transition mechanism.

“If all we are doing is repeating what we agreed in Brazil a full year ago, why have we brought everyone to Türkiye for two weeks?” asked Adow. “Communities living with drought, floods and failed harvests were promised action. They cannot survive on an annual renewal of the same promises.”

At a separate press conference on Friday morning, a group of mainly European, Latin American and Pacific nations ministers gathered to promote the transition away from fossil fuels – which is not explicitly mentioned in the draft text.

Marshall Islands environment minister Jess Gasper said that for the Pacific transitioning away from fossil fuels “is not a political choice – it is a matter of survival”.

IEA-inspired carbon capture goal draws campaigner criticism

The inclusion in Thursday’s draft cover text of a global target for carbon capture, utilisation and storage (CCUS) has drawn criticism from many climate campaigners, who call it a dangerous distraction from transitioning away from fossil fuels. The EU also has said it does not want CCUS in the COP31 decision.

CCUS consists of technologies that capture carbon dioxide from emitting facilities like a power station or cement plant and either store it – usually in underground reservoirs – or use it in industrial processes like making drinks fizzy. If the gas does not reach the atmosphere, it does not contribute to global warming.

The COP31 draft text calls – in square brackets, meaning it is undecided – for CCUS to aim to capture 2.5 gigatonnes (Gt) of carbon dioxide a year by 2035. A weaker alternative calls for a target of 0.5Gt “and to work towards” 1.3-2.5Gt.

These figures stem from the International Energy Agency’s 2024 World Energy Outlook, with 1.3 Gt the target from the less ambitious “Announced Pledges Scenario” and 2.5Gt from the more ambitious 1.5C-aligned “Net Zero Emissions Scenario. The IEA’s head Fatih Birol has said that CCUS is “critical for ensuring our transitions to clean energy are secure and sustainable”.

The IEA’s report says this carbon dioxide could be captured from energy, industry and to make low-carbon hydrogen. It also says that, based on announced projects, the world is well off track to meet these figures. Currently only 0.05GT can be captured each year and governments like the UK are warning they will cut investment.

Oil and gas producers Saudi Arabia and Russia are the main supporters of climate action focusing on CCUS as it allows for continued fossil fuel use. In a press conference earlier this week, Europe’s Climate Commissioner Wopke Hoekstra opposed suggestions that CCS “might be the solution for everything” without giving further details. Small islands have also historically been opposed to CCS promotion.

Some climate campaigners have called for the target to be deleted. Romain Ioualalen, global policy lead at Oil Change International, said the target “gives dangerous credibility to disproven technologies like CCS that will trap us in our dependence on the volatile fossil fuel economy”.

He added: “These CCS paragraphs are a real and immediate danger to the energy transition and need to be removed. This isn’t a pathway out of the crisis – it’s a license to prolong it.”

But COP31 President of Negotiations Chris Bowen defended the language. He said that “the IPCC and IEA have said we’re going to need CCUS as part of the net zero 1.5C scenario”.

He added that he understands CCUS is “not many people’s first choice” and that it shouldn’t be used as an excuse to delay emission reductions.

In response to a question from Climate Home News, E3G senior associate Alden Meyer said that CCS is “a small part of the solution to climate change but it needs to be focussed on hard to abate sectors like steel, cement and others”. It should not be seen as a credible solution for transportation, buildings, electricity, which represent the vast majority of carbon dioxide emissions”, he said.

He added: “The fact that there’s so much attention to CCS, both around the halls and in this press conference, demonstrate, to some extent, the success of the Saudi strategy of trying to distract us from the need to stop buying so much of their product”.

As well as the numerical target, Thursday’s draft text says governments are “recognising the role of CCUS, particularly in hard to abate sectors”. The EU has previously said that CCUS should be limited to these sectors, like cement, rather than used in easy-to-clean-up sectors like electricity generation.

China issues last-minute backing of 35×35 electrification voluntary pledge

On the last official day of COP31, China announced through its state-run news agency that it supports an electrification target promoted by the Turkish and Australian co-presidency, in a rare move from the Asian giant, which has played a low-key role at the climate talks in recent years.

The 35×35 electrification pledge seeks to increase the share of electricity in final energy consumption to 35% by 2035, up from the current 23%. It was included in the second draft of the COP31 cover decision, the main negotiated outcome in Antalya.

In the joint communiqué with Australia, Beijing said it recognises the importance of accelerating electrification and it welcomed international cooperation to achieve the 35×35 voluntary pledge, also referring to its multiple benefits for employment, energy security, and public health.

China is already a major actor driving global electrification through its vast clean energy exports and rapid adoption of solar, wind and electric vehicles. The International Energy Agency (IEA) estimates the country will surpass 40% of electricity in final energy consumption by 2035.

The country also restated its commitment to limiting the “magnitude and duration” of a now-unavoidable overshoot past the Paris temperature goal of 1.5C of global warming. Including a strong message on limiting this overshoot has been one of the main battles in Antalya.

The statement also highlights the role of free trade and condemned climate measures that “constitute a means of arbitrary or unjustifiable discrimination or a disguised restriction on international trade”. The language is similar to last year’s COP30 decision which was seen as a big win for China despite the EU’s pushback on it.

The current COP31 draft recognises the decarbonisation benefits of open international trade, and invites countries to “share relevant information” on the impacts of trade measures through the UN’s trade and climate change dialogue.

Veteran analyst and director of the China Climate Hub at the Asia Society, Li Shuo, said the statement was “carefully timed” and could help preserve the electrification target in the cover decision, after a push from Russia and Saudi Arabia to remove sectoral targets.

He added that the joint announcement may have been “carefully curated” as President Xi Jinping and Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese met Friday on the sidelines of the APEC Economic Leaders’ Meeting in Shenzhen.

Small island states and a group of Global North and South nations say the draft decision is too weak on issues ranging from the transition away from fossil fuels to finance provision