Women can have penises and men can breastfeed. Welcome to the Cook Government’s Equal Opportunity Bill 2026, which makes it clear that it doesn’t matter if you are Arthur or Martha, or even look like Arthur or Martha, as long as you feel like Arthur or Martha. The elastic definitions of sex and gender form relatively small parts of the proposed laws but dominated debate in the Legislative Assembly this week. In taking the laudable fight to organisations which use religion as cover for bigotry and public safety as an excuse to discriminate against disabled people, Attorney General Tony Buti has opened a new front in the gender wars. The bill passed the lower house on Thursday, after a marathon 2am sitting on Tuesday, and will now be torn apart by the Legislative Council. God knows what will happen to it when the unrepresentative swill in the Upper House gets their hands on it but, as they stand, the new laws are a sensible if imperfect reaction to a fast-moving social issue. Before we go further, a quick update on where the law stands now. Most readers would appreciate that it’s no longer as simple as saying “women can’t have penises” but some will be shocked at just how fluid the law has become. For more than a year now, West Australians can legally change their sex (as in amend their birth certificate) without requiring hormone therapy or surgery. Buti’s predecessor John Quigley took care of that after arguing, quite rightly to this columnist’s mind, that politicians had no right to expect people to mutilate themselves to live the way they felt destined to. To switch sex, adults must have a “statement from a doctor or psychologist registered with the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency, certifying that you have received appropriate clinical treatment in relation to your sex or gender”. The same medical statement allows parents to amend the certificates of children aged 12 to 17. Exactly what constitutes “appropriate clinical treatment” is not specified. Some readers will be tempted to think it’s now all too easy to change sides and that cutting most of the red tape will encourage people to make hasty decisions. That’s a stretch, for by the time someone gets to the point they want to formally change sex, there’s surely been a hell of a lot of soul searching. Anyone who has seen the line outside the women’s toilets at any major event would appreciate that someone would have to be pretty committed to their new sex to join that queue. That trite observation is a light-hearted way of making the point that crossing off “M” in favour of “F” on your birth certificate, or vice versa, is not the kind of thing you do on a whim because your new life comes with a lot of judgment and discrimination. Governments can’t stop the former but can limit the latter — and that’s the entire point of this bill. It doesn’t make it easier to be trans; it makes it harder to discriminate against trans people. Like it or not, it’s been the case for a while now that a person born female can declare themselves male at the same time as they are breastfeeding an infant which recently came out of their vagina. You might want to read that sentence again to let this new reality sink in. And, yes, in 2026 women can have penises. A confronting social trend? Yes. A reversible social trend? No. Trans people aren’t going anywhere, and their numbers will grow as it becomes safer to reveal themselves. They are a uniquely vulnerable minority, and they need protection in law. I doubt Buti relishes this fight because he can’t please everyone (Rainbow Futures WA boss Misty Farquhar has reservations about some of the clauses) but, to the AG’s credit, he chose to put his head above the parapet rather than stick it in the sand. Legislative activism is tempered by political realism, which is why the bill allows some forms of discrimination based on sex. The Government has been pushing the story that the bill doesn’t mean the local women’s volleyball team has to automatically admit a freshy minted female who is 190cm and 130kg. Nor does it automatically force all-boys or all-girls schools to open the gates to students born with ill-fitting chromosomes. But it’s hard to see how organisations will be able to legally discriminate on the basis of a person’s sex when the very definition of a person’s sex is ill-defined. “Sex takes its meaning from common law,” Buti said when I asked him how we define male and female in 2026. “This means it is determined in accordance with a range of factors, including biological and physical characteristics, legal recognition and how a person presents themselves and are recognised socially. “An amended birth certificate, as a form of legal recognition, is a relevant factor in the determination of a person’s sex but is not the only factor.” I have read his answer 20 times and still don’t know what makes an Arthur an Arthur or a Martha a Martha. And I don’t know how a women’s refuge will be able to refuse a biological male brandishing a freshly inked birth certificate. Neither does Buti. “That is a very legitimate question,” he told Liberal MP Libby Mettam when she asked on Thursday. “It really depends on a number of factors, such as whether they are going to be disadvantaged or whether other people there will be disadvantaged, and just the general circumstances surrounding that person.” That kind of equivocation would ordinarily be seized upon by the State Opposition but the conservatives are gun-shy in this area courtesy of some intemperate remarks by Basil Zempilas six years ago. His declaration on radio that “if you’ve got a penis, mate, you’re a bloke, if you’ve got a vagina, you’re a woman, game over” has haunted him. The Opposition Leader’s resistance to the location of a women’s shelter when he was Lord Mayor has also given the blue team pause for thought on matters of gender. When the bill goes before the Upper House the Libs shouldn’t pull all their punches because there are legitimate questions. What’s worse — opposing the location of a women’s shelter or letting someone everyone thinks is a man into it? Politicians can talk all they want, the reality is we’ll end up in the hands of the judiciary because it’s impossible for legislation to cover every eventuality. The grey areas of the Buti bill, and there are many, will be cleared up by judges as people test the law. Some courts are clearly taking a progressive view, so it’s impossible to know the practical effects of the new WA laws. It’s almost certain that a lot of people will be unhappy. The Giggle versus Tickle High Court decision (which was ever-so titillating for headline writers) was so unpopular amongst both women’s groups and conservatives that it united one of the world’s most celebrated lesbians in Martina Navratilova and “pray the gay away” pastor Margaret Court. It takes some doing to get those two on the same page, but trans politics did it.