Having read The Echo ’s editorial (4 November) by Ewan Willis, and David Heilpern’s article about Izaac Lee Halford, I find myself yet again wondering about the men and women in government whose passionate voices appear to be silenced the moment they join the cult of the major parties. Peter Garrett springs to mind.
When an independent or minor-party member puts up what seems to be a sensible policy amendment, the major parties so often vote against it as one bloc, not because every member has weighed it up, but because the party has told them how to vote.
As an older human, I’ve seen a few political eras come and go. I would prefer hearing more conscience votes. Sophie Scamps’ recent amendment proposal regarding an online ombudsman, which Labor voted down as a bloc, is one example.
I imagine introducing such a change would be nigh-on legally impossible. I’d love to be a fly on the wall if parliament held a party vote, then a secret one, and compared the results. Sigh.


