Government defends its rejection of sex abuse bill
18 November 2026, 1:43pm
A state government has been accused of cruelty to victims of child sexual abuse for not allowing them to sue institutions such as churches and sporting clubs.
The Queensland government has defended its decision to vote down a private member's bill to close a legal loophole, saying it risks creating legal uncertainty and exposing victims to protracted litigation.
The bill if passed would have allowed institutions to be held vicariously liable for abuse claims if the alleged perpetrator's connection with the institution was akin to employment.
The bill, put forward by shadow attorney-general Meaghan Scanlon, was in response to a 2024 High Court decision limiting the rights of child sex abuse victims to sue institutions such as churches, sporting clubs or volunteer groups.
In rejecting the bill, the government missed an opportunity to close a legal loophole and effectively sided with institutions that failed to protect children from abuse, Ms Scanlon said.
"That is appalling, cruel and shows that their support for victims is merely lip service."
Slater and Gordon Lawyers, a leading compensation and class-action law firm, said the government's decision to vote against the bill and not allow debate on it on Tuesday night was deeply disappointing.
The law firm's Head of Abuse Law, Stephanie Brown, told AAP the loophole allowed institutions to avoid responsibility if a perpetrator did not meet a narrow definition of "employee".
So a school could be sued as being vicariously liable for a teacher's abuse but a church school could avoid being sued because an accused priest teaching there was technically not an employee of the church, she said.
The same loophole could apply to volunteers at sports clubs or other community groups if they were not classified as employees.
This proposed common-sense reform would have made it clear that organisations, religious or voluntary, could be held to account for abuse committed on their watch, Ms Brown said.
Victoria, the ACT and recently Western Australia had all taken action to close the loophole, Ms Brown said.
"Now we have a situation of jurisdictional lottery, where if you happened to be abused in Victoria or ACT you have more rights as a survivor than you do in Queensland."
A spokesperson for Queensland Attorney-General Deb Frecklington said the government acknowledged the pain and lifelong consequences suffered by victims and survivors of historical child sexual abuse.
"Labor has attempted to capitalise on a complex legal environment and propose legislation that risks legal uncertainty and unintended consequences, including exposing victims to protracted litigation."
Parliament's justice committee noted the bill relied on the central concept of a relationship "akin to employment" without providing sufficient guidance as to the relationships that would fall within that test.
1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732)
National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028




