Perth ratepayers are staring down the barrel of a $50,000 legal black hole after a near half empty council chamber rejected a controversial proposal for an LGBTQIA+ sex club. At Tuesday night’s meeting, councillors voted 3-2 in favour of the exclusive CBD venue, but the proposal was sensationally torpedoed because four elected members failed to show up. Councillors Catherine Lezer, David Goncalves, Adam Pacan and Raj Doshi were not at the meeting, which meant the application didn’t receive a majority vote as required and didn’t pass. The decision leaves the City facing a costly State Administrative Tribunal showdown that experts warn they are destined to lose. The city’s own planning director and sustainability director Maria Cooke has admitted the case is so indefensible that three separate planning firms have flat-out refused to defend the council in court. The city has already spent about $10,000 on the tribunal proceedings, with a further $30,000 to $50,000 estimated for a full hearing, excluding staff time. At Tuesday’s meeting, Cr Chris Patton said he was “not comfortable” putting ratepayers through an expensive legal fight he believed the city was unlikely to win. “I’m not comfortable putting ratepayers through a lengthy and expensive legal battle against one of Perth’s top law firms, when I believe there’ll be a real likelihood that the city will lose,” he said. “That’s not a responsible use of ratepayers’ money, particularly when we have other priorities and projects that deserve those resources. “If I genuinely believed we had a strong and defensible planning position, I would have no hesitation in voting against it.” He said his vote in favour of approval did not mean he personally supported the venue, but reflected his consideration of the planning advice and potential financial consequences. Cr Liam Gobbert, who also voted for approval, said there was no planning merit in refusing the application and warned council members against allowing personal opinions to influence statutory planning decisions. “That would be bad governance,” he said. Lord Mayor Bruce Reynolds, who moved the club be approved, said he was still not satisfied the proposed use was appropriate for the location. “I’m just built in a certain way that I cannot approve something that I don’t agree with the amenities in space and place of this,” he said. “That’s just the way it is unfortunately.” Cr Viktor Ko referred to the city’s own LGBTQIA+ plan, which he said says “very clearly” the city should support safe zones for LGBTQI people. “Unfortunately, it doesn’t actually specifically prescribe a permanent private member-only venue,” he said. “This application itself, essentially, is a privately operated member-only venue, accommodating activities, so this is what dictates my decision. “No matter how I twist it, I cannot seem to fit it with with this plan. This is a promise that I had to the LGBTQIA community and I’ll stick to it; that is why I’m voting against this application.” The amended proposal would have reduced the patron numbers from 50 to 35, limited approval to five years, and restricted entry to registered members, with no walk-ins or casual guests permitted. City planning officers had recommended approval, saying the amended management plan addressed concerns around safety, emergency procedures, cleaning and safer sex standards. The failed motion leaves the city facing the prospect of having to defend its refusal at the SAT, despite warnings about the strength of its case and the cost to ratepayers.