Try getting a roomful of VCs excited about a woman opening a restaurant.

She’s bootstrapped, putting her house up as security, signing a two-year lease, and hiring six people before selling any product. She’s a passionate founder, with belief in her vision and talent.

I used to review restaurants for a living. And I’m reasonably confident the woman who signed the lease took a bigger risk than a VC partner who ordered the fish entree using me&u.

So after being in business, and covering a range of industry sectors as a journalist for 30-plus years, I’m at a loss to understand why founders selling the chef booking software deserve a better capital gains tax (CGT) discount than she does.

Related Article Block Placeholder Article ID: 342807

Allegra Spender: CGT carve-out plan would hit Australia’s top startup investors

That’s why Allegra Spender’s alternative to the Innovative Business CGT Concession ( IBCC) passes the pub test.

Smarter business news. Straight to your inbox.

For startup founders, small businesses and leaders. Build sharper instincts and better strategy by learning from Australia’s smartest business minds. Sign up for free.

By continuing, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy .

The Wentworth MP wants a 40% CGT discount on active business assets, including shares and employee options. Not just for startups, but for anyone with the guts and determination to start a business.

The tweak lets the Labor government address its original premise: changing the tax treatment for investment properties to make housing more affordable (a policy debate for another column).

Meanwhile, the chef and software founder can both work out what share of future gains will be taxed without having to argue over and apply to the government about being sufficiently innovative.

Why is the “backbone of the nation” politicians love to mention when talking about small business suddenly not worth the lumbar support when it comes to tax?

I told a Senate committee looking into the issue after the budget CGT changes were announced that the case for recognising entrepreneurial risk applied to startups and small businesses alike. Having gone there, benefited from the CGT discount after a great exit, and backed startups (not yet successfully), it’s a bit rich to forget the small business half of that argument once tech has been offered its own concession.

Set the DeLorean for 1985

The year Back to the Future hit cinemas, Paul Keating introduced Australia’s broad CGT for the first time (incidentally, he also ruined my long lunches with fringe benefits tax).

Indexation had a sensible purpose. If you bought an asset for $100, sold it later for $110, and prices rose 10% in the meantime, where’s the gain? The tax rules also allowed averaging to soften the impact of booking years of gains in a single tax return — something I believe should return more broadly for investors and business owners who have a windfall in a single tax year.

By 1999, John Ralph’s Review of Business Taxation gave the Howard government reason to revisit the paperwork. Then-Treasurer Peter Costello froze indexation, abolished averaging and introduced the 50% discount for people who held eligible assets for at least 12 months. We were becoming a nation of shareholders after a range of privatisations, including Telstra, CBA and Medibank, and Costello was keen to encourage investment and make it easier for people to get their tax right.

“I have great doubts whether people are complying with it,” he said of the old system.

And now, 27 years on, his successor, Jim Chalmers, is taking the DeLorean back to indexation for gains accrued from July 2027. It’s a bollocks plan that does nothing for a businessperson who starts with nothing, but a decade later, faces a tax bill for the sweat equity they poured into the company. If the RBA’s current punitive measures have their intended impact, inflation will fall and it’s academic except to anyone with a paperwork obsession.

Related Article Block Placeholder Article ID: 347625

Chalmers revises CGT rules for startups, but R&D funding concerns remain

Given Dr Jim‘s PhD in political science was on Keating, I can only assume he fell for the former PM and treasurer’s famed declaration about dense, technical laws: “ The legislation is complex because the issues are complicated.”

Labor’s Innovative Business CGT Concession is an example of why this government needs a Minister for Unintended Consequences examining its policy decisions. The legislation is not an integrity measure, it’s a Jobkeeper program for Canberra’s tax bureaucracy.

To keep issuing qualifying equity, a company has to show each year that more than half of at least two of three things – its assets, workers and income – relate to qualifying innovation.

Costello was worried about people looking up CPI figures last century. Now, we’ve got a test to decide who can use the shortcut.

Chalmers has objected to the Spender plan, but it borders on gaslighting, given the cost of compliance in the Labor plan. CPA Australia sees it costing business hundreds of millions . Great for their revenue, but most tell me it’s not work they want because it does nothing to help build successful businesses.

Yes, some startup people will pay more under Spender’s proposal – I hope you’re sitting down when you hear the Treasurer is concerned about paying more tax at the point where he’s increasing the taxes on business and investors, because this alt universe is making me dizzy.

But let’s break it down. On a $1 million gain, a founder entitled to Labor’s 50% discount would declare $500,000. At 40%, it’s $600,000. For someone already on the top marginal rate, that’s another $47,000 in tax, including Medicare.

Now go back to the day your OG engineer was debating whether to take less pay in return for shares. They already made a call on the product and your vision for success. But how do they price in the chance that a change in what the business does years later may or may not wipe out the concession on those shares?

This is a discussion about risk, but how much should individuals have to wear when the house (ie. government) always wins.

Chalmers said he’s written to Spender after Treasury examined her proposal. I wish I had Dr Jim’s confidence in their advice after watching the IBCC being built to look like a camel by economics seeking a horse.

Related Article Block Placeholder Article ID: 345387

“Definitely losing talent”: Startup leaders fear tax settings pushing Aussie founders overseas

Treasury doubts Spender’s proposal would be simpler, fairer or more productive, and sees scope for people to game it. Chalmers wants to target companies whose innovations benefit the wider economy. Fair enough. Show us where the rule can be gamed and let’s fix it. I run startup awards. Picking the most innovative business in the room is hard enough when the prize is a trophy. I’d be reluctant to let the judges loose on anyone’s tax return.

The Parliamentary Budget Office reckons Spender’s alternative could raise $590 million more than Labor’s model with the startup concession in place. It acknowledges gaps in the data. On the numbers we do have, the Treasurer can afford to give the idea a hearing.

Greens senator Nick McKim spoke to Spender, called her idea “very interesting” and is open to a Senate inquiry about it. The Greens votes to pass the Labor legislation is still up in the air with a fortnight of parliamentary sittings left in 2026. With the Coalition opposed, that matters rather more to Labor’s pre-Christmas timetable than another press release from a peak body.

The Business Council, the Council of Small Business Organisations Australia (COSBOA), the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ACCI) and Ai Group have backed the broader discount.

My advice to founders and VCs is to sign Spender’s open letter and tell senators why you’d support a change to the government’s current plan that could cost you personally, because it gives another business owner a fairer go.

There’s a win for everyone in that. The chef gets a greater reward for their sweat and cleverness, and more business owners still have plenty of cash from an exit for a slap-up celebratory meal in her restaurant.

And if you go to Canberra to meet with senators or the government, take a chef whose food you love and appreciate with you. They can explain what it took – the hours and risk to build the restaurant – you enjoy.

And the software founder can book the table.

Never miss a story: sign up to SmartCompany’s free daily newsletter and find our best stories on LinkedIn .

Simon has been editor of Startup Daily since 2019. He hosted the Startup Daily show on streaming service ausbiz.com.au from 2020 to 2023, and now, the weekly podcast Startup 360. He was previously associate editor of Business Insider Australia, a national restaurant critic, editor of The Good Food Guide, and newspaper proprietor during a 30-plus-years career in journalism and publishing. He’s also an investor in early stage startups.

Recommended for you

David Adams Aug 11, 2026

Small business investment, trust structures singled out in Spender tax proposal

David Adams Mar 12, 2026

Capital gains tax: What the rumoured budget reforms mean for small business

David Adams May 4, 2026