You should read “ The Why and How of Foreign Aid “, published in the Journal of Economic Perspectives , partly because of who wrote it. Professor Dean Karlan was chief economist at the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) from November 2022 until he resigned in February 2025. His reflections are worth hearing and some of the paper’s best parts describe reforms written into USAID funding calls that were cancelled as the agency was dismantled.
The framework is straightforward. The “why” of aid is allocative efficiency: which problems, which countries and who benefits (recipient, donor or everyone, through global public goods). Cost-benefit analysis is the tool.
Productive efficiency is the “how”: for a given problem, how do we do the most per dollar? Cost-effectiveness analysis is the tool and evidence is central, using it where it exists and producing it where it does not. A program can be cost-effective and still fail a cost-benefit test if it efficiently solves the less important problem.


