A Melbourne homeowner is facing a bill of more than $1 million after their viral TikTok video criticising a building company resulted in $883,000 in court-awarded damages. Legal costs and interest is expected to push his total liability beyond seven figures.

Gurvinderpal Singh was ordered to pay $105,000 each to Singh Homes directors Parvinder Singh Sarwara and Daman Preet Singh Anand on October 28, on top of the $673,000 awarded to their company, Singh Homes.

Related Article Block Placeholder Article ID: 347059

Fake one-star Google reviews flood custom cellar business after The Block appearance

The dispute centred on a Punjabi-language video that attracted around 220,000 views and circulated widely within Melbourne’s Indian community.

Richard Hutchings, a building and construction partner at Cornwalls law firm, told SmartCompany the case was “a win for small business”.

“People build up reputations, livelihoods, businesses, and they can be undermined quite easily by people engaging in online criticism and dressed up as a review,” he said.

Smarter business news. Straight to your inbox.

For startup founders, small businesses and leaders. Build sharper instincts and better strategy by learning from Australia’s smartest business minds. Sign up for free.

By continuing, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy .

From building dispute to viral TikTok backlash

The dispute began when Singh hired Singh Homes to construct a house in Truganina, in west Melbourne.

The relationship deteriorated over disagreements over construction work and payments, and the building contract was terminated in February 2024.

Singh then posted a TikTok video in Punjabi voicing his complaints against the company and its directors.

The video was viewed around 220,000 times, mainly by the Punjabi-speaking Indian community, and shared via WhatsApp.

A jury found the video conveyed defamatory allegations about Singh Homes’ directors, including that they were dodgy builders, neglected customers and made unreasonable demands for payment.

The jury also found that comments beneath the video conveyed allegations that Singh Homes was going into liquidation and its directors were unqualified and ripped off customers.

The jury rejected truth defences to several of the allegations.

As a result, Singh Homes was awarded $673,000 over claims of injurious falsehood and misleading or deceptive conduct, including financial losses linked to lost business opportunities.

Singh Homes told the court that approximately 12 prospective customers abandoned plans to build with the company following the allegations.

Related Article Block Placeholder Article ID: 345499

“Pay us or the reviews stay”: The extortion scam targeting Australian small businesses

How the damages became a $1 million-plus bill

The case then made its way to the Victorian Court of Appeal after County Court Judge Julie Clayton found the directors hadn’t established the serious reputational harm necessary to pursue their defamation claims.

However, in August 2026, the Court of Appeal overturned Judge Clayton’s ruling and found the evidence collectively established serious harm to the directors’ reputations.

In her October 28 judgment , Clayton subsequently awarded each director $100,000 in general damages and $5,000 in aggravated damages.

Anand said he received around 40 to 45 calls about the video, including calls from overseas.

Sarwara testified that he felt like he was being shunned by members of the community following the video and that he was questioned regularly about the company’s financial position.

In awarding aggravated damages, Clayton also considered Singh’s decision to leave the video online until around July 2025, despite repeated requests for its removal.

Singh told the court his complaints about the builder were genuine. But the court rulings mean he has been ordered to pay a total of $883,000 in damages to Singh Homes and its directors, with legal costs and interest expected to take his total liability beyond $1 million.

SmartCompany contacted Singh Homes and Gurvinderpal Singh’s legal representatives for comment. Neither responded before publication.

What the ruling means for small businesses and online reviews

Hutchings said the case highlights the financial risks facing people who make serious allegations against businesses on social media.

“It doesn’t really change the law. It’s just a good example of how people going too far and saying things that don’t have a proper basis for, can be liable, and the damages can be very significant.”

Hutchings said consumers are still able to raise legitimate complaints and fair criticism, but he warned damaging allegations can spread further than intended, particularly when shared through community groups or across social media platforms.

“It just shows that with the power of free speech comes the responsibility to exercise that in a reasonable, and fair way,” Hutchings said.

Related Article Block Placeholder Article ID: 347176

Small businesses face mandatory audits under costly new online safety rules

Hutchings also warned that people who share or republish potentially defamatory content made by other people can face separate legal liability.

“[People] should not assume that online is a safe space, where they can say whatever they want,” Hutchings said.

The Court of Appeal did not decide whether ordinary customers’ negative reviews could breach Australian Consumer Law, meaning the ruling sets no precedent for businesses to sue simply because someone leaves a bad review.

Never miss a story: sign up to SmartCompany’s free daily newsletter and find our best stories on LinkedIn .

Digital Business Journalist

Simon Thompson has worked across print, television and radio in Australia, the UK and the United States. His reporting has covered business and financial markets, immigration, politics and water policy. He previously covered UK and European private equity in London and has reported for NPR and PBS-affiliated outlets in the US. Simon studied journalism and politics at Monash University.

Recommended for you

Andrew Leigh flags crackdown on “tricky tactics” after Fernwood gym cancellation goes viral on TikTok

David Adams Jun 16, 2026

Amazon drone delivery goes haywire in viral video

Kate Weber Aug 21, 2026

AI spokesperson helps Vodafone ads hit two million views

Tegan Jones Sep 9, 2025