News

Poland’s Rule-of-Law Crisis Deepens as Rival Judges Claim Control of Top Court

November 2, 2026 12:30

An attempt to replace the leadership of Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal has brought a row over judicial independence to a head, pitting the government against the president and raising fresh questions about the limits of their powers.

A decade-long dispute over who controls Poland’s highest court escalated over the weekend, when a group of judges sought to remove its leadership, police were deployed to the building, and President Karol Nawrocki cut short a foreign trip to intervene.

The next flashpoint is seen on Tuesday, November 3, when Anna Korwin-Piotrowska – one of the five judges elected by the current parliamentary majority but prevented from taking up their duties by the country’s president – has called a general assembly of Constitutional Tribunal judges to approve the court’s proposed budget for 2027. With the existing leadership, led by the court’s president Bogdan Swieczkowski, continuing to dispute her authority, it remains unclear whether the meeting can proceed as planned.

The battle over the makeup of the Constitutional Tribunal, which has the power to overturn laws that violate Poland’s constitution and should act as an independent check on government and parliament, dates back to 2015, when both the outgoing centrist government and its right-wing successor made contested appointments to it. During Law and Justice’s (PiS) subsequent eight years in power, major reforms to the judiciary raised concerns over political interference and brought Poland into prolonged conflict with European institutions over the state of the rule of law in the country.

Reversing those reforms was among Donald Tusk’s central campaign promises before his coalition took office in 2023, and his pro-European government has made restoring the court’s independence an essential part of repairing the country’s democratic institutions. The Tusk-led government has since refused to recognise the Tribunal’s legitimacy in its current form, but attempts to change the system through legislation have been blocked by opposition-aligned presidents.

The immediate deadlock concerns five judges elected by the current parliament whom Nawrocki has refused to swear in. These judges subsequently took their oaths without him, but the Tribunal’s leadership prevented them from hearing cases. In October, the Venice Commission, the Council of Europe’s constitutional advisory body, concluded that the president could not use his role in the appointment process to obstruct duly elected judges from taking office.

However, PiS and President Nawrocki accuse Tusk of using unlawful methods to replace the court’s leadership with judges sympathetic to his government.

The competing claims came to a head on Friday, when the five judges attempted to assert their authority over the Tribunal. Korwin-Piotrowska announced the suspension of its president, Swieczkowski, and his deputy, and declared herself the court’s acting head. The existing leadership rejected the move, leaving the institution with rival claims to authority.

Separately, Justice Minister Waldemar Zurek sought to have Swieczkowski and his deputy, Bartlomiej Sochanski, stripped of judicial immunity, potentially paving the way for criminal charges over their alleged obstruction of the Tribunal’s work.

The announcement brought more protesters to the Tribunal’s grounds in Warsaw, where supporters of the opposition had already been demonstrating for weeks against attempts by the newly elected judges to take up their posts. Senior PiS politicians joined the crowd, while police increased their presence around the building.

Meanwhile, President Nawrocki cut short a state visit to Senegal, ordering his plane to turn around over Spain and return to Warsaw. He arrived at the Tribunal in the early hours of Saturday, challenged the authority of the judges seeking to take control, and helped the court’s deputy president enter the building.

“Last night, Poland’s constitutional order was violated, and a constitutional state institution was forcibly taken over,” Nawrocki said in a statement issued shortly after 05:00 on Saturday morning. He demanded that police withdraw from the premises and announced emergency consultations with parliamentary party leaders.

In a televised address on Saturday evening, Prime Minister Tusk defended the intervention, accusing PiS and the PiS-aligned presidents Andrzej Duda and his successor Nawrocki of perpetuating the crisis. “Nobody had any doubt that the Tribunal, in the form imposed by PiS, was not a real court,” he said, arguing that repeated attempts to resolve the dispute through legislation had been blocked.

Tusk compared the situation to a thief who steals an elderly woman’s handbag, then complains of violence when caught, while bystanders suggest dividing the stolen money between the thief and the victim. “On certain matters, there can be no compromise,” he said.

A constitutional reset to end an undignified row?

Poland’s Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights, a leading civil liberties organisation, questioned whether Friday’s intervention by the government would help restore the Tribunal’s authority, calling the escalation “extremely harmful”.

“The confrontations between judges and the President of the Republic of Poland outside the entrance to the Tribunal building undermine the dignity and authority of state institutions,” the organisation said in a statement.

The European Commission weighed in on Saturday, backing the Polish parliament’s authority to appoint Tribunal judges. Meanwhile, US Ambassador Tom Rose warned that crowds outside the court risked worsening an already volatile situation. “The last thing Poland needs is a confrontation that spirals out of control,” he wrote on X, while stressing that Washington did not intend to interfere in Poland’s domestic affairs.

With parliamentary elections scheduled for 2027, Tusk’s coalition faces pressure to deliver on its promise to restore judicial independence, while the opposition has made resistance to the government’s intervention a central issue. In August, Tusk announced that he was determined to ensure the newly elected judges could take up their posts at the Tribunal by September, even if the process was not particularly elegant. Speaking at the Campus Polska Przyszlosci event, he said he needed to be certain that “our judges will enter that building”.

On Saturday afternoon, Nawrocki held meetings with parliamentary party leaders to discuss possible solutions. Among the proposals put forward by parties as far apart as the left-wing Razem and the far-right Confederation was a constitutional reset of the Tribunal, involving the replacement of all its sitting judges with a new bench appointed through a cross-party agreement.

Constitutional Court

European Commission

‘Life on Hold’: Poland’s Immigrants Face Years Waiting for Residence Permits

Warsaw’s Political Fight with Kyiv Is Being Settled on Polish Streets

One Year in the Palace: How Nawrocki Made the Polish Presidency His Own