The United States’ move to keep more critical-mineral scrap at home could strengthen supply security, but its success will depend less on how much material stays in the country than on how much domestic industry can turn into usable minerals.

Later in August, some lithium-ion battery scrap, including black mass, and tungsten scrap will have to be sold to US buyers unless an adjustment or exception applies, according to the Financial Times . The one-year measure is designed to retain strategically important material as Washington seeks to reduce reliance on foreign processing capacity.

The logic is compelling. If the US needs more critical minerals, why export material that already contains them? But scrap is not the same thing as supply. It still must be collected, sorted, processed and refined into products that battery, defence and industrial customers can use.