Annual budgets are consistently subject to criticism, particularly regarding contentious tax policy issues. In 2026-2027, debate focused on the government’s commitment to reform negative gearing – a policy permitting property investors to deduct rental property losses from taxable income – and to introduce a capital gains tax on specific assets. The capital gains tax applies to profits realised from the sale of investments, taxing only the increase in value at the point of sale.
In response to these concerns, Mr Chalmers asserted that breaking a promise to voters may be justified if undertaken for “ right and justifiable reasons .” Public opinion on this issue remains divided. Proponents argue that breaking promises can be necessary to adapt to evolving circumstances, address unforeseen challenges, and prioritise the broader public interest.


