The idea is simple: protect kids from harm. But here’s the problem – this ban won’t do what it promises. In fact, it risks making things worse.
I’m writing this now because the conversation has started in Canberra and across dinner tables, but it’s framed in the wrong way. We’re treating YouTube accounts as the danger when the real risks – and opportunities – lie deeper.
Where the Policy Fails
Ban accounts, and kids won’t stop watching YouTube. They’ll just watch without logging in. That means:
More ads : Hours of wasted time, even on educational content.
Less oversight: No-watch-history means parents can’t see what their kids are consuming.
No protection. YouTube still personalises content even without accounts.
This is the illusion of safety. The government can claim it has acted, while the actual risks – addictive design, cyberbullying, data harvesting – continue unchecked.
What we lose in the process
YouTube isn’t just cat videos. It’s one of the most powerful learning platforms ever created. My son uses it to learn coding, explore history, and even experiment with making his own videos with AI tools. Banning accounts means stifling the very creativity and digital literacy we should be encouraging.
Get the best of Startup Daily straight to your inbox
Want to know the latest in startup news? Subscribe to our daily news and analysis coverage on what’s happening to ANZ startups, investors and the broader ecosystem. And best of all, it’s FREE!
By continuing, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy .
Think about it: our kids will grow up in a world where digital and AI skills are as fundamental as reading and writing. Do we really want to shut the door on a platform that helps them build those skills?
What we should be talking about
The real problem isn’t that children have accounts – it’s that the platform is engineered to keep them hooked. YouTube Shorts are the digital equivalent of junk food: addictive by design, irresistible in the short term, but harmful in the long run.
That’s where policy should focus.
Imagine regulations that target addictive design, enforce age-appropriate settings, and demand stronger protections in comment sections.
That’s how we protect kids – not by pretending the problem disappears when you remove the “log in” button.
Why this matters now
We’ve seen this playbook before. Policymakers go for simple, headline-grabbing bans instead of tackling the harder, structural issues.
But this matters because the digital and AI world isn’t going away.
The choices we make today will shape whether the next generation grows up as passive consumers or active creators.
And here’s the thing: young people themselves have insights we ignore at our peril. My son understood the trade-offs better than most adults debating this policy. If we don’t involve them in shaping solutions, we’ll keep repeating the same mistakes.
My view is simple:
Australia’s YouTube ban for under-16s is a distraction. It creates the illusion of safety while undermining learning and creativity. If we want real impact, policymakers need to go after addictive design, demand transparency from platforms, and – most importantly – bring young voices into the debate.
Because the question isn’t whether kids should be on YouTube. The question is: how do we prepare them to thrive in a digital and AI world that won’t wait until they turn 16?
Will Liang is the CEO of Amplify AI Group .
Will Liang is the CEO of Amplify AI Group, a firm dedicated to solving the finance industry’s hardest problems through AI and data innovation. With over 18 years of leadership across Macquarie Group, MA Financial, and KPMG, Will has helped shape the future of technology in financial services. He is a globally recognised AI leader -named a LinkedIn Top Voice, Global Top 100 Data Leader, and Top 100 CIO in Asia. In 2024, he received an honorary fellowship from UTS for his work in AI education and won the 2023 Asian Australian Leadership Award in the corporate category. Will has delivered 20+ keynotes on AI in the past year.
Recommended for you
IT’S ON: The Australian government is adding YouTube to its social media ban for under 16s
Michelle Grattan Jul 30, 2025
While everyone argues over adding YouTube to Australia’s u16 social media ban, the AI elephant in the room is set to trample on kids
Tama Leaver Jun 24, 2025
Google comes out swinging over government including YouTube in its under 16 social media ban
Tom Williams Oct 15, 2025

