By Gonzo Snark
This week’s Guardian report warned that U.S. broadcasters may face license trouble if they go “negative” on Trump. That’s the polite version. The real danger is sharper: speaking truth to power is being reframed as grounds for cancellation.
FCC commissioner Brendan Carr, a Trump appointee, leaned on broadcasters after Jimmy Kimmel mocked MAGA politics. Within days, ABC affiliates in several markets pulled the show .
The FCC’s own guidelines insist it is barred from censoring content or punishing viewpoints (FCC FAQ). Yet here we are, with commissioners brandishing licensing threats like weapons.
Sliding Door #1: The Law Holds
America still has guardrails:
The Supreme Court banned prior restraint in Near v. Minnesota (1931).
In NRA v. Vullo (2024) , the Court unanimously ruled officials cannot coerce intermediaries (banks, insurers – and yes, broadcasters) to punish disfavoured speech.
If the FCC ever tried to yank a license for satire, it would almost certainly lose in court.
Sliding Door #2: Fear Rules

