News

EU Increases Pressure on Montenegro to Alter Intelligence Agency Law

July 30, 2025 16:07

Brussels says authorities in EU-candidate country must explain planned legal changes to ‘sensitive sector’ that local NGOs say threaten fundamental rights.

Montenegrin Parliament Committee on Security and Defence session, July 30 2025. Screenshot: YouTube/Skupština Crne Gore

Montenegro’s government is under growing pressure from the European Union, civil society organisations and opposition lawmakers to halt or revise a draft law on the national intelligence agency, which critics say threatens fundamental rights and weakens democratic oversight.

The country’s parliamentary Committee on Security and Defence on Wednesday adopted a report on the draft Law on the National Security Agency – fast-tracked by the government earlier this month without broad consultation – paving the way to adopt the legislation before the end of July.

The proposed changes would grant the security agency, the ANB, extensive access to personal and institutional data, including banking information, telecommunications metadata and civil society registries, without needing prior court approval.

The European Commission has called on the Montenegrin authorities to explain the legal basis and necessity of the changes.

“We are closely following developments related to this draft law,” Guillaume Mercier, spokesperson for the European Commission, told Vijesti newspaper. “Any legislative changes in this sensitive sector must be transparent, legally justified, and open to comprehensive legal analysis.”

Several Montenegrin NGOs have warned that the draft law endangers citizens’ constitutional rights and violates the country’s international legal obligations.

“This law presents an extreme risk to the rights of citizens,” the groups said in a joint statement. “We urge the government to withdraw it and open a space for expert and public debate during the fall session.”

The organisations have also addressed the UN Special Rapporteur on privacy rights and urged Montenegrin lawmakers not to proceed before international experts have reviewed the draft.

The government claims it made limited changes to eight articles of the bill, but critics say these revisions are cosmetic.

The most controversial provision would allow the ANB to collect telecommunications metadata, including location and traffic data without judicial oversight, despite a 2014 Constitutional Court ruling that such a practice is unconstitutional.

Justice Minister Bojan Bozovic said on Monday that one of the amendments would now require access to electronic databases to be based on an agreement between the ANB and the institution that owns the data.

“It is true that we received recommendations from a UN committee in April to include a court decision in addition to those agreements, but colleagues from the ANB believe that would be an excessive burden on both the agency and the courts,” Bozovic told parliament’s Committee on Defence and Security on Wednesday.

Another amendment says access to telecommunications and location data must now be approved by the Supreme Court, rather than just the ANB director, as originally proposed.

Bozovic said he was paying attention to the European Commission’s views.

“We are listening closely to reactions from Brussels and won’t do anything that could slow our [EU accession] progress,” he said. “When it comes to Chapter 23 and the work of the Justice Ministry, if our actions delay the accession process, that would logically reflect on my own position as well.”

Tea Gorjanc Prelevic, of the NGO Human Rights Action, said more than 20 civil society organisations have called for the bill to be withdrawn and submitted to a full public consultation.

“This proposal concerns human rights and Montenegro must guarantee their protection if it wants to join the EU,” she said. “You are now giving the ANB the authority to demand information from journalists, dentists and psychiatrists without any court order. That is deeply concerning.”

Opposition MPs, including lawmakers from the Democratic Party of Socialists, DPS, have echoed these concerns. “This law must not create legal loopholes that enable abuse of power or erode trust in national institutions,” DPS MP Nikola Janovic warned on Tuesday.

The proposed law comes at a sensitive moment in Montenegro’s efforts to join the European Union. The EU has emphasized that reforms to the security and intelligence sector are vital for progress in the accession process.