Subletting startup Kiki’s decision to shut down its New York operations has now drawn an official response from the city’s Office of Special Enforcement, the department responsible for enforcing short-term rental laws.

In an email to investors, seen by SmartCompany , Kiki cited “regulatory uncertainty” as the reason for winding down its operations in New York and signalled plans to launch in a new city soon.

A Kiki spokesperson later acknowledged to SmartCompany that the startup “operates in grey regulatory areas” and stated this was “not uncommon in tech startups”.

Related Article Block Placeholder Article ID: 318443

Subletting startup Kiki exits NYC, admits regulatory ‘grey area’

In a video posted to social media, co‑founder and CEO Toby Thomas‑Smith said the city of New York told Kiki it needs to stop all stays under 30 days, pointing to the likes of Airbnb as the reason for the law.

The Office of Special Enforcement (OSE) has now responded to Kiki leaving the New York City.

Smarter business news. Straight to your inbox.

For startup founders, small businesses and leaders. Build sharper instincts and better strategy by learning from Australia’s smartest business minds. Sign up for free.

By continuing, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy .

The OSE is responsible for enforcing the city’s short-term rental regulations. This includes Local Law 18, which prohibits rentals of entire homes for fewer than 30 days unless the host is present and registered with the city.

The agency declined to directly address Kiki’s shutdown in New York, citing a continuing investigation. However, it did appear to challenge the startup’s claims of ambiguity.

“The goal of our office is to gain compliance with laws that protect the city’s residents, guests, and housing stock — as well as deterring those that seek to profit by breaking those laws,” a spokesperson for the Office of Special Enforcement said to SmartCompany.

“Our laws are straightforward and provide certainty for all who wish to operate here: hosts must be registered, and booking services must verify those registrations before processing transactions.”

Local Law 18 was established in New York City in 2022. Kiki, which started in New Zealand and later launched in Sydney, entered the New York market in 2023.

Internal investment committee documents from 2023, seen by SmartCompany , reveal Kiki’s primary investor, Blackbird Ventures, was aware of the legal risks before investing .

Related Article Block Placeholder Article ID: 312587

Blackbird’s internal report flagged Kiki’s legal risks before US launch

The firm asked Kiki how it would respond if it received cease and desist letters from the city.

In response, Thomas-Smith said that scenario would be a “pioneering moment” for the startup and outlined two possible actions: “keep going (ignore NYC government)” and “build a lobbying team”.

Two years on, the company is leaving the city and has said Kiki “is not in a financial position that we can work with the city on this”.

Turbulent years for Kiki in New York

Kiki entered the New York market in 2023 after raising US$6 million in seed funding led by Blackbird Ventures.

The company projected aggressive growth, telling investors it would reach US$2.5 million in monthly revenue and fill 31,000 homes within its first year in the US.

Related Article Block Placeholder Article ID: 311985

Kiki’s investor reports reveal millions burned amid legal risks

But as SmartCompany previously reported , it brought in just US$76,000 over 10 months and filled only 459 homes.

By November 2024, the company reported having US$3.8 million in the bank. But investor updates and social media also showed funds were being used for discretionary spending, including a 300-person rooftop party and proposed monthly offsites for staff.

A rent guarantee initiative introduced in late 2024 cost the company US$13,000 in a single month, with a later investor update describing the program as financially unsustainable at its current scale.

Despite being in operation for seven years, Kiki’s platform has also remained highly manual, with only 30% automation as of November 2024. Around-the-clock staffing was still required to keep the system functional at the time.

As of May 2025, a beta version of the website was in operation that was locked behind invite-only codes. Documents seen by SmartCompany showed listings under 30 days were still being advertised on the invite-only site.

Related Article Block Placeholder Article ID: 285924

Blackbird breaks silence on Kiki’s high-profile pivot from sub-letting to NYC ‘girls’ club’

Investor reports in 2024 revealed further inconsistencies, varying in structure and clarity. Some included cash-on-hand figures, while others did not. Metrics like “revenue” and “booked revenue” were used interchangeably, and updates often referenced unconventional KPIs, such as “rent saved.”

Kiki also experienced high staff turnover during its US expansion, including the departure of two co-founders and several early employees over the past 18 months.

In early 2024 Kiki also received backlash after briefly rebranding as a women-only social club called Girls Who NYC, despite being run by men. This prompted a return to its original subletting model.

Given Local Law 18 was already in effect before Kiki’s US launch, the rebrand has raised questions about whether it was an attempt to reposition the business away from short-term rental compliance risks.

Related Article Block Placeholder Article ID: 287374

Kiki and Blackbird say the “girls only” club is still committed to subletting

Kiki has not yet revealed where it plans to launch next. But Thomas-Smith has left the door open for a return to New York if conditions change.

“We did actually everything we could say there. We looked at every possible scenario. We tried everything. New York meant everything to us, and so we can come back when the city’s ready to work together,” he said.

Never miss a story: sign up to SmartCompany’s free daily newsletter and find our best stories on LinkedIn .

A multi-award-winning journalist, Tegan has been reporting on technology, telecommunications and gaming for the past 10 years. She regularly appears on mainstream media channels as an expert tech commentator. Her previous roles include editor of Gizmodo Australia and global reviews editor at Finder. She has also served as a reporter and editor across Business Insider, Lifehacker and Kotaku Australia. Tegan is also the co-host of one of the top technology podcasts in Australia, Weird Tech. You can find her on Twitter @Tegan_Writes.

blackbird ventures

Recommended for you

Kiki pays US$152,000 settlement in New York over ‘unverified’ short-term rentals

Tegan Jones Nov 20, 2025

Tegan Jones Jun 18, 2025

Kiki relaunches in London, confirming new home after NYC exit

David Adams Jun 24, 2025